When it comes to mid-range digital pianos, the Yamaha YDP-165 and Roland RP701 are two models that stand out for their performance, features, and build quality. Designed for home use, these pianos aim to provide a rich acoustic experience while offering the convenience of modern digital functionality. In this detailed review, we will compare the two across several crucial categories: design, keyboard, sound, speakers, functions, connectivity, value for money, and other relevant factors. By the end, you’ll have a clear picture of which piano suits your needs better.
Yamaha YDP-165 vs Roland RP701 Comparison Chart
Here’s a comprehensive comparison table outlining the specifications and features of the Yamaha YDP-165 vs Roland RP701:
If you click the links below, under the product images you will be redirected to Amazon.com. In case you then decide to buy anything, Amazon.com will pay me a commission. This doesn’t affect the honesty of this review in any way though.
| Feature | Yamaha YDP-165 | Roland RP701 |
|---|---|---|
 |  | |
| Check best price on Amazon | Check best price on Amazon | |
| Design | Traditional upright style | Modern minimalist design |
| Dimensions (W x D x H) | 53.5″ x 16.6″ x 33.4″ | 54″ x 13.5″ x 31.3″ |
| Weight | 89 lbs | 82 lbs |
| Keyboard Action | Graded Hammer Standard (GHS) | PHA-4 Standard (Progressive Hammer Action) |
| Key Material | Plastic keys, matte black finish | Synthetic ivory and ebony textures |
| Escapement | No | Yes |
| Polyphony | 192 notes | 256 notes |
| Sound Engine | CFX Sampling | SuperNATURAL Piano (hybrid modeling + sampling) |
| Voices/Tones | 10 voices | 324 tones |
| Speakers | 20W (2 x 10W, 12cm speakers) | 24W (2 x 12W, 12cm speakers) |
| Modes | Dual, Duo | Dual, Split, Twin Piano |
| Recording | 2-track MIDI recording | MIDI and audio recording |
| Bluetooth | Not available | Bluetooth MIDI and audio |
| Audio Outputs | None | Yes |
| USB Ports | USB-to-Host only | USB-to-Host and USB-to-Device |
| Pedal Unit | 3 pedals: damper, sostenuto, soft | 3 pedals: damper (Progressive Action), sostenuto, soft |
| App Integration | Smart Pianist (wired connection required) | Piano Every Day (wireless with Bluetooth) |
| Color Options | Black, White, Dark Rosewood | Contemporary Black, White, Light Oak, Dark Rosewood |
| Extras | Simple and intuitive setup | Advanced tone shaping and customization |
| Target Audience | Beginners and intermediate players | All levels, especially creative and advanced players |
| Price Range | Lower | Slightly higher |
| My product reviews | Yamaha YDP-165 review | Roland RP701 review |
Key Takeaways from the Table:
- The Yamaha YDP-165 is tailored for players who prefer simplicity, traditional aesthetics, and a piano-like feel, with core features focused on straightforward functionality.
- The Roland RP701 offers a more advanced and versatile setup, appealing to players looking for modern connectivity, a larger sound library, and a superior playing experience.
For those seeking tradition and reliability, the Yamaha YDP-165 is a great choice, but for cutting-edge features and more dynamic performance, the Roland RP701 is the clear winner.
Design and Build Quality: A Closer Look
When comparing the Yamaha YDP-165 and the Roland RP701, their design and build quality are among the most important aspects to consider. These two digital pianos are designed with home use in mind, and both aim to deliver an elegant, piano-like aesthetic that fits seamlessly into living spaces. Let’s dive deeper into their construction, material choices, finishes, ergonomics, and overall visual appeal.
Yamaha YDP-165: Traditional Elegance with a Focus on Piano Aesthetics
The Yamaha YDP-165 is part of Yamaha’s popular Arius series, which prioritizes a timeless, classic piano design. This model embodies the look and feel of an acoustic upright piano, making it a great choice for players who value tradition.
Construction and Materials
The cabinet of the YDP-165 is made from high-quality MDF (medium-density fiberboard), which is a common material in digital pianos at this price point. Yamaha has finished the MDF with a synthetic wood veneer that gives the piano a polished and realistic wood-like appearance. While it doesn’t use real wood, the attention to detail in the veneer finish ensures that the instrument feels and looks premium.
The pedal unit, stand, and keyboard area are sturdy and well-constructed, contributing to a robust build that will last for years with proper care. The pedals are made of metal, giving them a weighty, durable feel that mimics the pedals of an acoustic piano.
Color Options
The YDP-165 is available in three color finishes: Black, White, and Dark Rosewood. Each option has its unique appeal:
- Black: A classic choice that exudes sophistication and blends well into most interiors.
- White: Ideal for modern or minimalist spaces, adding a touch of brightness.
- Dark Rosewood: For those who prefer a more traditional or warm aesthetic.
Ergonomics and Functionality
The piano’s dimensions make it compact yet substantial enough to command attention in a room. At 53.5 inches wide, 16.6 inches deep, and standing 33.4 inches high, it’s well-suited for small to medium-sized rooms. However, its depth and width are slightly larger than the Roland RP701, making it feel closer to a traditional upright piano.
The height of the keyboard relative to the bench is standard for pianos, providing a comfortable playing position for most users. The integrated music stand is wide enough to hold multiple sheets of music or a tablet, and the three-pedal setup is seamlessly integrated into the stand, adding to the overall aesthetic while being functional.
Visual Appeal
The Yamaha YDP-165’s design is traditional and understated, making it ideal for players who want their digital piano to resemble a classic acoustic upright. It doesn’t feature any modern embellishments or flashy design elements, which could be a downside for those seeking a contemporary look. However, for players who value tradition, the YDP-165 is a visually pleasing instrument.
Roland RP701: Modern Minimalism Meets Practicality
The Roland RP701 strikes a balance between contemporary and traditional design. Roland has crafted this model to appeal to modern sensibilities while still retaining the core elements of a digital piano. The result is a design that is sleek, clean, and highly functional.
Construction and Materials
Like the Yamaha YDP-165, the RP701’s cabinet is made from MDF, but Roland has opted for a textured wood grain finish that adds a tactile element to the piano’s surfaces. This finish not only enhances the visual appeal but also makes the piano less prone to showing fingerprints or scratches compared to smoother finishes.
The build quality of the RP701 is excellent, with tight seams, a sturdy pedal unit, and a solid overall structure. The pedals are also metal, and they incorporate Roland’s Progressive Damper Action, which enhances the realism of the playing experience.
Color Options
The RP701 is available in four finishes, providing a slightly wider range of choices than the YDP-165:
- Contemporary Black: A versatile option that fits into almost any décor.
- White: A sleek, modern choice that stands out in minimalist environments.
- Light Oak: A unique finish that provides a natural, Scandinavian-inspired aesthetic.
- Dark Rosewood: A more traditional option for those who appreciate a classic piano look.
The variety of finishes ensures that the RP701 can complement a broader range of interior design styles compared to the YDP-165.
Ergonomics and Functionality
One of the most noticeable design advantages of the RP701 is its compactness. Measuring approximately 54 inches wide, 13.5 inches deep, and standing 31.3 inches high, it is slightly shallower and shorter than the YDP-165. This makes it particularly well-suited for smaller spaces or apartments, where every inch of floor space matters.
The RP701 also features a streamlined music stand and control panel. Unlike the Yamaha model, the RP701’s controls are tucked away, giving the piano a clean, uncluttered appearance. This design choice not only enhances the aesthetic but also ensures that players can focus on the music without being distracted by buttons or displays.
Visual Appeal
The RP701’s design leans toward modern minimalism. The textured finish, clean lines, and slightly more angular edges give it a contemporary vibe, making it a great fit for modern homes or studios. The addition of a light oak finish, in particular, sets it apart from the YDP-165 and makes it an appealing option for those who prefer a natural wood look.
Comparing Design Philosophies
The design philosophies of the Yamaha YDP-165 and Roland RP701 cater to slightly different audiences:
- The Yamaha YDP-165 prioritizes a traditional, acoustic-piano-inspired design that appeals to purists. It mimics the classic upright piano in appearance, which is ideal for players who want their digital piano to blend seamlessly with more traditional home décor.
- The Roland RP701, on the other hand, blends tradition with modernity. Its compact design and clean lines make it a better fit for players who prefer a contemporary aesthetic or have limited space.
Both pianos are constructed with similar materials and exhibit excellent build quality. However, the RP701’s textured finish and additional color options give it a slight edge in versatility, while the YDP-165 excels in delivering a traditional upright piano experience.
Durability and Long-Term Appeal
In terms of durability, both models are built to last with proper care. The MDF construction and synthetic finishes are resistant to everyday wear and tear, though they may be more susceptible to damage from excessive moisture or heat compared to solid wood. The sturdy pedal units on both pianos ensure consistent performance over time, and the overall build quality inspires confidence in long-term use.
From a long-term aesthetic standpoint, the Yamaha YDP-165’s timeless design ensures that it won’t go out of style, even as trends change. On the other hand, the Roland RP701’s modern design is more likely to appeal to younger players or those with a taste for minimalist, contemporary décor.
Final Verdict: Design and Build Quality
Choosing between the Yamaha YDP-165 and Roland RP701 in terms of design and build quality ultimately depends on personal preference. If you value a classic piano aesthetic and don’t mind slightly larger dimensions, the YDP-165 is an excellent choice. For those who appreciate a sleek, modern look and need a compact instrument, the RP701 stands out as the better option. Both pianos are exceptionally well-built, ensuring they will be centerpieces in your home for years to come.
Keyboard Action and Feel: A Detailed Comparison
The keyboard action of a digital piano is arguably its most critical feature. It bridges the gap between the digital and acoustic worlds, directly affecting how natural and enjoyable it feels to play. Both the Yamaha YDP-165 and Roland RP701 aim to replicate the touch and response of an acoustic piano, but they do so in different ways. Here, we’ll explore the materials, mechanisms, responsiveness, and overall playability of each model’s keyboard in detail.
Yamaha YDP-165: Reliable Graded Hammer Action
The Yamaha YDP-165 features Graded Hammer Standard (GHS) action, a tried-and-true keyboard mechanism commonly found in Yamaha’s entry-level and mid-range digital pianos. While it is not Yamaha’s most advanced action, the GHS delivers a solid playing experience that will satisfy beginners and intermediate players.
Graded Hammer Standard (GHS) Action
The GHS action replicates the heavier touch in the lower registers and lighter touch in the higher registers, similar to the key weight distribution of an acoustic piano. This graded response is essential for players who want a realistic feel and is particularly useful for building proper finger strength and technique.
- Key Weighting: The weighting is noticeably heavier in the bass keys and becomes progressively lighter as you move toward the treble. This makes the YDP-165 a good training tool for transitioning to acoustic pianos.
- Responsiveness: The action is consistent across the keyboard, making it suitable for various playing styles, from delicate classical pieces to more dynamic compositions.
Key Materials and Texture
The YDP-165’s keys are made of high-quality plastic, with a matte finish on the black keys to reduce slipperiness. While the material provides a comfortable playing experience, it lacks the tactile refinement of higher-end synthetic ivory or ebony finishes.
- Realism: The smoothness of the white keys and the subtle grip of the black keys strike a good balance for most players. However, the absence of textured surfaces on the white keys may be noticeable for those accustomed to higher-end digital or acoustic pianos.
- Durability: Yamaha’s keys are known for their longevity, resisting wear and maintaining their functionality even after extensive use.
Touch Sensitivity
The YDP-165 offers three levels of touch sensitivity, allowing you to adjust the keyboard’s response to your playing dynamics:
- Soft: Ideal for lighter playing or those with a softer touch.
- Medium: The default setting, which provides a balanced response for most styles.
- Hard: Best for players with a more forceful touch or those who prefer a wider dynamic range.
While the touch sensitivity adds some customization, the overall response of the GHS action may feel slightly mechanical compared to more advanced hammer-action systems.
Limitations
Although the GHS action is reliable and responsive, it lacks some of the refinements found in Yamaha’s higher-end actions, such as GH3 or NWX. These more advanced systems include features like escapement and synthetic key textures, which bring the playing experience closer to that of an acoustic piano. For players seeking absolute realism, the GHS action may feel less nuanced.
Roland RP701: Enhanced Playability with PHA-4 Standard Action
The Roland RP701 takes a step forward in realism and playability with its PHA-4 Standard keyboard action. This mechanism is designed to provide a highly authentic touch, catering to both beginners and experienced players who demand more from their instrument.
PHA-4 Standard Action
The PHA-4 (Progressive Hammer Action) Standard keyboard offers graded weighting similar to Yamaha’s GHS system, but with added refinements that elevate its performance.
- Key Weighting: The PHA-4 mimics the progressive weighting of an acoustic piano, but the transition between registers feels smoother and more natural. The added escapement mechanism enhances realism, simulating the subtle “click” felt in acoustic pianos when a key is pressed lightly.
- Escapement: This feature adds an additional layer of authenticity, as it replicates the slight resistance found in acoustic piano keys when they are depressed slowly. While it might not be essential for beginners, advanced players will appreciate the nuance.
Key Materials and Texture
Roland’s PHA-4 keys are made from high-quality plastic, but they are coated with synthetic ivory and ebony textures. This feature greatly enhances the tactile experience compared to the smoother plastic keys of the YDP-165.
- Synthetic Ivory and Ebony: The textured finish provides better grip and a more premium feel, even during extended playing sessions. These surfaces mimic the materials used in traditional acoustic piano keys, offering a more sophisticated touch.
- Durability: Roland’s keys are highly resistant to wear and maintain their texture over time, ensuring a consistent playing experience for years.
Touch Sensitivity
The PHA-4 Standard action offers multiple levels of touch sensitivity, similar to Yamaha’s GHS system. However, the dynamic range feels wider, and the keyboard responds more fluidly to subtle changes in pressure, making it ideal for expressive playing.
Refinements
One of the key advantages of the PHA-4 Standard is its quiet action. Roland has engineered the keys to reduce mechanical noise, which is particularly beneficial during practice sessions in shared living spaces. This quietness doesn’t come at the expense of tactile feedback, ensuring a satisfying playing experience.
Comparing the Two Keyboards
| Feature | Yamaha YDP-165 (GHS) | Roland RP701 (PHA-4 Standard) |
|---|---|---|
| Weighting | Graded, heavier in bass | Graded, heavier in bass, smoother |
| Escapement | Not included | Included, simulates acoustic feel |
| Key Material | Plastic with matte black keys | Plastic with synthetic ivory/ebony |
| Touch Sensitivity | Adjustable, 3 levels | Adjustable, wider dynamic range |
| Quietness | Moderate | Quieter, optimized for home use |
| Overall Realism | Suitable for beginners/intermediates | Suitable for all skill levels |
Realism and Playability
While both keyboards deliver a satisfying playing experience, the Roland RP701’s PHA-4 Standard action stands out for its enhanced realism, tactile refinement, and escapement mechanism. The inclusion of synthetic ivory and ebony textures provides a premium feel, making the RP701 more appealing for advanced players or those transitioning from acoustic pianos.
Suitability for Beginners and Intermediate Players
For beginners, the Yamaha YDP-165’s GHS action is reliable and provides an excellent starting point. Its graded weighting and responsive touch sensitivity are more than adequate for building foundational skills. However, intermediate and advanced players may find the action somewhat limiting compared to the more nuanced PHA-4 Standard.
Conclusion: Which Keyboard Action is Better?
In the battle of keyboard action and feel, the Roland RP701 emerges as the clear winner. Its PHA-4 Standard action offers a more authentic and refined playing experience, thanks to its escapement mechanism, textured keys, and quiet operation. While the Yamaha YDP-165 delivers solid performance with its GHS action, it lacks the advanced features and tactile enhancements that make the RP701 truly stand out. If realism and premium touch are priorities, the Roland RP701 is the superior choice. However, for beginners seeking a reliable and straightforward playing experience, the Yamaha YDP-165 still holds significant appeal.
Sound Quality: An In-Depth Analysis
The sound quality of a digital piano is one of its most defining features, as it directly influences the playing experience and overall enjoyment. Both the Yamaha YDP-165 and the Roland RP701 deliver impressive sound quality, but they approach this in distinct ways, reflecting their respective brand philosophies. In this expanded section, we’ll explore the sound engines, polyphony, tonal realism, sound projection, and overall tonal versatility of these two models.
Yamaha YDP-165: A Focus on Warm, Authentic Acoustic Tones
The Yamaha YDP-165 utilizes the brand’s CFX Sampling Technology, a hallmark of Yamaha’s digital piano lineup. This sound engine is based on samples from Yamaha’s flagship 9-foot CFX Concert Grand Piano, one of the most revered instruments in the world.
CFX Sampling: Rich, Warm Tones
The CFX sound engine captures the nuanced tones of the Yamaha CFX grand piano. This means the YDP-165 offers a rich and warm sound profile, making it ideal for classical music, ballads, and softer compositions.
- Dynamic Range: The dynamic response of the CFX engine allows for expressive playing. From soft pianissimo passages to bold fortissimo chords, the YDP-165 handles changes in dynamics smoothly, making it a suitable choice for expressive pieces.
- Tonal Character: The sound is rich in the midrange, with sparkling highs and a controlled bass response. This tonal balance makes the YDP-165 particularly appealing for solo piano performances.
Polyphony: 192 Notes
The YDP-165 offers 192-note polyphony, ensuring that even complex pieces with overlapping sustain and rapid note repetition play without dropped notes. While 192-note polyphony is sufficient for most players, it is worth noting that it lags behind the RP701’s 256-note polyphony, especially for advanced users.
Sound Customization and Effects
The YDP-165 includes a range of sound customization options to enhance its tonal versatility:
- Reverb: Simulates the acoustics of different environments, from small rooms to large concert halls.
- Brilliance Adjustment: Lets users tweak the tonal brightness, adding depth or sparkle as needed.
- Damper Resonance: Simulates the harmonic resonance of strings when the damper pedal is pressed.
While these features add flexibility, they are relatively basic compared to the more extensive tone-shaping tools available on the Roland RP701.
Strengths and Limitations
The Yamaha YDP-165 excels in delivering authentic acoustic piano sounds, particularly for players who prefer traditional, warm tones. However, its reliance on sampling alone (rather than a hybrid modeling approach) can make the sound feel less dynamic and interactive compared to pianos with advanced modeling technology. For instance, the resonance and decay lack the organic quality that modeling-based engines can achieve.
Roland RP701: Realism Through SuperNATURAL Modeling
The Roland RP701 leverages Roland’s proprietary SuperNATURAL Piano Sound Engine, a hybrid technology combining sampling and modeling to produce lifelike, interactive sound.
SuperNATURAL Piano Sound Engine
Unlike purely sampled sound engines like Yamaha’s CFX, the SuperNATURAL engine uses behavioral modeling to recreate how an acoustic piano responds to a player’s touch and technique. This approach offers several advantages:
- Organic Interaction: The tone evolves naturally based on how the keys are played, mimicking the dynamic response of a real piano. This means subtle differences in playing strength or touch result in audible tonal variations.
- Natural Decay: One of the standout features is the way notes decay naturally, without the abrupt cutoff often associated with sampled tones. This adds a layer of realism, especially during sustained passages or legato playing.
- Resonance Simulation: The RP701 excels in simulating string resonance (how neighboring strings vibrate when a note is played) and damper resonance (the interaction between the damper pedal and the strings).
Polyphony: 256 Notes
The RP701 boasts an impressive 256-note polyphony, allowing it to handle even the most complex arrangements with ease. This is particularly beneficial for advanced players who frequently use layered sounds, rapid repetitions, or heavy sustain.
Sound Customization and Effects
Roland provides a more comprehensive set of tone-shaping tools compared to the Yamaha YDP-165:
- Ambience Effects: Includes adjustable reverb and spatial effects to replicate different environments.
- Equalizer: A built-in EQ lets players fine-tune the tonal balance to their liking.
- Adjustable Damper and String Resonance: These parameters can be tailored for a personalized sound.
The broader range of customization options ensures that the RP701 can adapt to various musical genres and player preferences.
Strengths and Limitations
The Roland RP701 excels in realism, offering a more interactive and dynamic playing experience than the YDP-165. Its modeling technology captures nuances that go beyond what sampling alone can achieve. However, some players may find its default tonal character slightly brighter and more modern compared to Yamaha’s warm and traditional tone.
Sound Projection: Speakers and Clarity
Yamaha YDP-165
The YDP-165 features a 20W stereo speaker system, with two 12cm speakers mounted within the cabinet. These speakers deliver clear and balanced sound, with enough power to fill small to medium-sized rooms.
- Clarity and Volume: The sound is crisp and well-defined, though the bass response may feel slightly limited at higher volumes.
- Room Presence: While adequate for home use, the speaker system may struggle to deliver the immersive experience of a real acoustic piano in larger spaces.
Roland RP701
The RP701 is equipped with a 24W stereo speaker system, also featuring two 12cm speakers. The extra wattage provides a noticeable improvement in sound projection and clarity.
- Clarity and Volume: The RP701 produces a fuller, more robust sound that can comfortably fill larger spaces.
- Room Presence: Thanks to its more powerful speakers, the RP701 has better bass depth and dynamic projection, enhancing the overall playing experience.
Tonal Versatility: Beyond the Piano Voices
Yamaha YDP-165
The YDP-165 offers 10 built-in voices, including:
- Grand Pianos
- Electric Pianos
- Strings
- Organs
While these voices are well-sampled and sound great, the limited number makes the YDP-165 less versatile for players who want access to a broader palette of sounds.
Roland RP701
The RP701 includes a much larger library of 324 tones, ranging from acoustic pianos to electric pianos, strings, brass, and even synthesizers.
- Variety: This extensive library makes the RP701 a more versatile instrument, suitable for a wider range of genres.
- Layering and Splitting: The ability to layer and split sounds adds creative flexibility.
Comparing Sound Quality: Summary
| Feature | Yamaha YDP-165 | Roland RP701 |
|---|---|---|
| Sound Engine | CFX Sampling | SuperNATURAL Hybrid Modeling |
| Polyphony | 192 Notes | 256 Notes |
| Customization | Limited Reverb and Effects | Advanced Tone Shaping Options |
| Speaker System | 20W, 2 x 12cm speakers | 24W, 2 x 12cm speakers |
| Tonal Versatility | 10 Voices | 324 Voices |
Conclusion: Which Model Offers Better Sound?
When it comes to sound quality, the Roland RP701 takes the lead. Its SuperNATURAL modeling engine delivers unparalleled realism, allowing for dynamic interaction and expressive playing. The RP701’s larger polyphony, more powerful speakers, and extensive sound library further enhance its appeal.
That said, the Yamaha YDP-165 excels in delivering the warm and rich tones of a traditional piano, making it a strong contender for those who value authenticity in classical music settings. For players seeking a more immersive and customizable experience, however, the RP701 is the superior choice.
Speaker System: Powering the Performance
The speaker system in a digital piano plays a crucial role in delivering the instrument’s sound to the listener. A well-designed speaker system enhances the richness, depth, and realism of the piano’s tone, making it feel more immersive. Both the Yamaha YDP-165 and Roland RP701 are equipped with high-quality speakers, but they differ in power, projection, and overall sound experience. Let’s take a closer look at how each model performs in this category.
Yamaha YDP-165: Balanced and Clear Sound for Home Use
The Yamaha YDP-165 features a 20W stereo speaker system with two 12cm speakers. The speakers are built into the piano cabinet and positioned to direct sound towards the player and outward into the room.
Power and Volume
The 20W output is suitable for small to medium-sized rooms, providing enough volume for home practice or intimate performances. While the system performs well in terms of clarity, it may feel slightly underpowered for larger spaces or situations where a more robust sound is desired.
Sound Quality
- Clarity: The speakers produce a clean and well-defined sound, faithfully reproducing the warm tonal qualities of the CFX concert grand sampling.
- Bass Response: While the bass is balanced, it lacks the depth and resonance that some players might expect, particularly at higher volume levels.
- Highs and Mids: The midrange and treble frequencies are prominent, providing clarity for melodies and upper-register passages. This tonal balance makes the YDP-165 a good choice for classical and solo piano performances.
Room Presence
For most home environments, the YDP-165’s speakers deliver a pleasant and immersive experience. However, players looking for a fuller or more room-filling sound may need to consider external amplification, as the speakers lack the dynamic punch necessary for larger spaces.
Roland RP701: Fuller, More Robust Projection
The Roland RP701 ups the ante with a 24W stereo speaker system. Like the YDP-165, it features two 12cm speakers, but the additional power enhances its sound projection and overall presence.
Power and Volume
With 24W of power, the RP701 delivers a noticeably stronger output, capable of filling medium to large spaces more effectively than the YDP-165. This makes it a better choice for those who want a richer sound without needing external amplification.
Sound Quality
- Clarity: The RP701’s speakers reproduce the detailed nuances of the SuperNATURAL sound engine with exceptional fidelity. The result is a tone that feels vibrant and expressive.
- Bass Response: The bass is more pronounced and resonant compared to the YDP-165, adding depth and warmth to the lower registers.
- Highs and Mids: The midrange is clear and articulate, while the treble frequencies are crisp without being overly sharp. This tonal balance ensures versatility across various genres, from classical to jazz and pop.
Room Presence
The RP701’s speaker system excels in creating a fuller, more immersive sound field. The added power and dynamic range provide a richer experience, whether you’re playing quietly or at higher volumes.
Comparing Speaker Systems
| Feature | Yamaha YDP-165 | Roland RP701 |
|---|---|---|
| Power | 20W (2 x 10W) | 24W (2 x 12W) |
| Speaker Size | 12cm x 2 | 12cm x 2 |
| Volume | Adequate for small/medium spaces | Better for medium/larger spaces |
| Bass Depth | Balanced, but slightly limited | Fuller and more resonant |
| Clarity | Clear and warm | Crisp and expressive |
Conclusion: Which Speaker System is Better?
The Roland RP701 has the advantage in this category, thanks to its more powerful 24W system, which provides greater sound projection and depth. It offers a more immersive experience, making it suitable for both home use and larger spaces.
That said, the Yamaha YDP-165 is no slouch. Its 20W system produces clear, warm tones that are ideal for intimate settings and casual practice. For players who prioritize a compact and straightforward sound setup, the YDP-165 delivers reliable performance. However, if you’re looking for a richer and more robust soundstage, the RP701 is the superior choice.
Functions and Features: Versatility Beyond the Keys
The Yamaha YDP-165 and Roland RP701 go beyond traditional digital piano functionality, offering various features that enhance playability, learning, and creativity. These functions make them not just digital instruments but comprehensive tools for practice, composition, and performance. In this section, we’ll compare the modes, sound libraries, recording capabilities, and app integrations of these two models to see how they cater to the needs of different players.
Yamaha YDP-165: Simplified and Intuitive
The Yamaha YDP-165 provides a straightforward set of features tailored for players who value simplicity and reliability. Its emphasis is on delivering a seamless and intuitive playing experience rather than overwhelming users with advanced options.
Playing Modes
- Dual Mode: This allows players to layer two sounds simultaneously, such as piano and strings, creating a richer and more textured tone. It’s great for performances that require added depth.
- Duo Mode: Also known as “teacher-student mode,” Duo splits the keyboard into two identical pitch ranges. This is especially useful for lessons, as both teacher and student can play in the same octave range.
These modes are intuitive to access and adjust, making them ideal for beginners and intermediate players who want to experiment without navigating complex menus.
Sound Library
The YDP-165 features a modest 10 built-in voices, which include:
- 3 Piano Voices (including the Yamaha CFX Grand)
- Electric Pianos
- Strings
- Organs
- Vibraphone
- Harpsichord
While limited in number, the voices are high-quality, with a strong emphasis on acoustic realism. This makes the YDP-165 well-suited for players focused on piano-centric music rather than exploring a variety of tones.
Recording and Playback
The YDP-165 includes a two-track MIDI recorder, enabling players to record and layer performances. This basic functionality is helpful for practice and composition, but it’s less versatile compared to Roland’s audio and MIDI recording capabilities.
Smart Pianist App Integration
The YDP-165 is compatible with Yamaha’s Smart Pianist app, which adds a layer of convenience and interactivity:
- Voice Control: Select voices, adjust settings, and configure modes directly from your smartphone or tablet.
- Chord Analysis: Load your favorite songs into the app, and it will analyze and display the chords for you to play along.
- Sheet Music Display: Access and view sheet music on the app for a more visual practice experience.
While the app enhances usability, it requires a cable connection, as the YDP-165 lacks Bluetooth connectivity.
Roland RP701: Feature-Rich and Modern
The Roland RP701 offers a more comprehensive suite of features designed to appeal to a broader audience, from beginners to advanced players.
Playing Modes
- Dual Mode: Like the YDP-165, this mode allows layering of two voices for a richer sound.
- Split Mode: Split the keyboard into two distinct voices, such as bass in the left hand and piano in the right. This feature is particularly useful for jazz and ensemble playing.
- Twin Piano Mode: Roland’s version of teacher-student mode, splitting the keyboard into two identical ranges for collaborative practice.
The addition of Split Mode gives the RP701 greater flexibility, making it suitable for more diverse musical styles.
Sound Library
The RP701 boasts an extensive library of 324 tones, far surpassing the YDP-165. In addition to acoustic pianos, it includes:
- Electric Pianos
- Strings
- Guitars
- Brass
- Synthesizers
- Percussion
This wide range of voices makes the RP701 ideal for players who want to explore different genres and experiment with sounds. It’s also a great tool for composing and arranging music.
Recording and Playback
The RP701 offers both MIDI and audio recording, enabling users to save performances as either MIDI files or high-quality audio files. This is a significant advantage for those who want to share recordings or use them in music production. The ability to record audio directly without additional equipment is a notable step up from the YDP-165.
Piano Every Day App Integration
The RP701 integrates seamlessly with Roland’s Piano Every Day app, offering a range of features:
- Practice Tools: Track practice time, set goals, and play along with exercises.
- Sheet Music Display: Access a library of sheet music and tutorials.
- Bluetooth Connectivity: Use the app wirelessly to control settings, select tones, and stream audio directly through the piano’s speakers.
The inclusion of Bluetooth MIDI and audio makes the RP701 far more convenient and user-friendly, eliminating the need for cable connections.
Comparing Features
| Feature | Yamaha YDP-165 | Roland RP701 |
|---|---|---|
| Modes | Dual, Duo | Dual, Split, Twin Piano |
| Sound Library | 10 Voices | 324 Tones |
| Recording | 2-Track MIDI | MIDI and Audio |
| App Integration | Smart Pianist (Cable Required) | Piano Every Day (Bluetooth) |
| Connectivity | USB to Host | USB to Host + Bluetooth MIDI/Audio |
Conclusion: Which Offers More?
The Roland RP701 is the clear winner in terms of features and functionality. With its larger sound library, advanced recording options, and seamless Bluetooth integration, it offers a more versatile and modern experience. It’s particularly well-suited for creative players who want to explore beyond piano playing.
On the other hand, the Yamaha YDP-165 excels in simplicity and delivers just enough features for traditional piano practice and performance. Its app integration and intuitive modes make it a great choice for beginners and those focused solely on piano-centric functionality. However, for players seeking more versatility and technological convenience, the RP701 has a significant edge.
Connectivity: Bridging Traditional and Modern Needs
In the modern age, connectivity is an essential aspect of any digital piano. It determines how well the instrument integrates with external devices, apps, and other technologies to enhance the playing and learning experience. The Yamaha YDP-165 and Roland RP701 cater to this need but with notable differences in their connectivity options. Here, we’ll examine the ports, wireless capabilities, and overall flexibility of each model.
Yamaha YDP-165: Functional Yet Limited
The Yamaha YDP-165 focuses on delivering a straightforward playing experience, and its connectivity options reflect this minimalist approach.
USB-to-Host
The YDP-165 features a USB-to-Host port, which allows the piano to connect to computers, smartphones, or tablets. This is particularly useful for:
- MIDI Communication: Players can use the piano as a MIDI controller with music production software like GarageBand, Logic Pro, or FL Studio.
- App Integration: It supports Yamaha’s Smart Pianist app, which enhances functionality by allowing users to control settings, select voices, and access sheet music.
However, the lack of a USB-to-Device port means that users cannot save performances directly to a USB flash drive. This limits the ability to transfer recordings conveniently.
Audio Output
The YDP-165 does not have dedicated audio outputs, which can be a drawback for those who want to connect the piano to external speakers, amplifiers, or recording equipment. While the built-in speakers are adequate for home use, players needing more robust amplification for performances may find this limitation frustrating.
Bluetooth
Unfortunately, the YDP-165 does not include Bluetooth connectivity. This means all app integrations and MIDI communications require a wired connection, reducing convenience and flexibility.
Roland RP701: Cutting-Edge Connectivity
The Roland RP701 offers more comprehensive connectivity features, making it a better choice for players who want greater versatility.
USB-to-Host and USB-to-Device
Like the YDP-165, the RP701 includes a USB-to-Host port for MIDI communication with computers and other devices. Additionally, it features a USB-to-Device port, allowing users to:
- Save performances directly to a USB flash drive in MIDI or audio format.
- Load custom sounds or MIDI files for playback.
Audio Output
The RP701 includes dedicated audio outputs, making it easy to connect to external speakers, amplifiers, or recording equipment. This is a significant advantage for musicians who plan to perform or record using professional-grade audio setups.
Bluetooth Connectivity
One of the RP701’s standout features is its Bluetooth MIDI and audio support. This wireless connectivity allows users to:
- Stream audio directly from a smartphone or tablet through the piano’s speakers.
- Use apps like Roland’s Piano Every Day without cables, offering greater freedom during practice or performance.
Comparing Connectivity
| Feature | Yamaha YDP-165 | Roland RP701 |
|---|---|---|
| USB-to-Host | Yes | Yes |
| USB-to-Device | No | Yes |
| Audio Outputs | No | Yes |
| Bluetooth MIDI/Audio | No | Yes |
Conclusion: A Clear Advantage for Roland
The Roland RP701 far outshines the Yamaha YDP-165 in terms of connectivity. Its inclusion of Bluetooth MIDI and audio, USB-to-Device functionality, and dedicated audio outputs make it a more versatile and modern choice. These features allow for seamless integration with external devices, apps, and professional audio systems, enhancing both practice and performance.
By contrast, the Yamaha YDP-165 offers the essentials but lacks the advanced connectivity features that many modern players expect. While it meets the needs of those who prioritize simplicity, its reliance on wired connections and the absence of audio outputs make it less suitable for players seeking more flexibility and convenience. For those who value advanced connectivity, the RP701 is the superior option.
Value for Money
Yamaha YDP-165
- Price: Slightly more affordable than the RP701, the YDP-165 represents great value for those prioritizing Yamaha’s reputation for reliability.
- Target Audience: Ideal for beginners and intermediate players who want a straightforward, no-frills piano experience.
Roland RP701
- Price: Slightly more expensive than the YDP-165, but justified by its superior features.
- Target Audience: Best suited for players who value modern connectivity, a premium keyboard feel, and advanced sound modeling.
Winner: Depends on Priorities
If budget is a key concern, the YDP-165 offers a high-quality experience at a lower price. For those willing to spend a bit more, the RP701 delivers greater value in terms of features.
Conclusion: Yamaha YDP-165 vs. Roland RP701 – Which One Should You Choose?
The Yamaha YDP-165 and Roland RP701 are both excellent digital pianos, but they cater to slightly different audiences. Choosing the right one depends on your preferences, skill level, and what you value most in a digital piano.
The Yamaha YDP-165 excels in delivering a traditional piano experience. With its elegant design, realistic CFX grand piano sampling, and reliable Graded Hammer Standard (GHS) action, it is an ideal choice for beginners and intermediate players who prioritize simplicity and authenticity. Its Smart Pianist app integration and user-friendly modes like Duo Mode make it a strong contender for students and hobbyists. However, its limited sound library, lack of Bluetooth, and basic connectivity options may feel restrictive to more advanced players or those seeking versatility.
On the other hand, the Roland RP701 stands out for its modern features and superior playability. Its PHA-4 Standard keyboard offers a more refined touch, while the SuperNATURAL sound engine delivers dynamic, expressive tones. The Bluetooth MIDI and audio connectivity, larger sound library, and USB-to-Device functionality make it a more versatile instrument, appealing to both creative and professional players. Its slightly higher price is justified by these additional features and advanced technology.
In summary, the Yamaha YDP-165 is best for those seeking a straightforward, traditional piano experience, while the Roland RP701 is the better choice for players looking for a versatile, feature-rich digital piano. Both pianos deliver exceptional quality, but the RP701’s modern enhancements give it a clear edge.