When selecting a digital piano, it’s essential to find an instrument that aligns with your musical goals, playing style, and practical needs. Two standout models in the mid-range category are the Roland FP-30X and the Casio PX-S1100. Both are highly regarded for their performance, portability, and features, making them popular choices for beginners, hobbyists, and even advanced players.
The Roland FP-30X is celebrated for its realistic piano action and warm, expressive tones, while the Casio PX-S1100 captivates players with its ultra-slim design, innovative Bluetooth capabilities, and lightweight build. These two pianos cater to slightly different audiences, but both promise an engaging and satisfying playing experience.
In this review, we’ll analyze every aspect of these instruments, from their design and keyboard feel to sound quality, functionality, and connectivity, to help you decide which one is the perfect match for your musical journey.
Roland FP-30X vs Casio PX-S1100 Comparison Chart
If you click the links below, under the product images you will be redirected to Amazon.com. In case you then decide to buy anything, Amazon.com will pay me a commission. This doesn’t affect the honesty of this review in any way though.
| Feature | Roland FP-30X | Casio PX-S1100 |
|---|---|---|
 |  | |
| Check the best price on Amazon | Check the best price on Amazon | |
| Keyboard Action | PHA-4 Standard with escapement and ivory feel | Smart Scaled Hammer Action |
| Number of Keys | 88 weighted keys | 88 weighted keys |
| Key Texture | Textured (ivory feel) | Smooth |
| Sound Engine | SuperNATURAL Piano Sound Engine | AiR (Acoustic and Intelligent Resonator) |
| Polyphony | 256 notes | 192 notes |
| Preset Sounds | 56 tones | 18 tones |
| Speaker System | 2 x 11W (22W total) | 2 x 8W (16W total) |
| Bluetooth | MIDI only | MIDI and Audio Streaming |
| USB Ports | USB Type-B (MIDI and audio), USB Type-A (storage) | USB Type-B (MIDI only) |
| Headphone Jack | 1/4-inch stereo | 1/8-inch stereo |
| Line Outputs | Dual 1/4-inch stereo | None (uses headphone jack for audio out) |
| Modes | Split, Layer, Twin Piano | Split, Layer, Duet |
| Recording | MIDI and audio (WAV to USB drive) | MIDI only (via app integration) |
| Pedal Support | Supports three pedals with half-pedaling (KPD-70) | Supports three pedals (SP-34), no half-pedaling |
| Metronome | Yes | Yes |
| Transpose | Yes | Yes |
| App Integration | Roland Piano Every Day App | Casio Music Space App |
| Portability | 31 lbs (14.8 kg), AC-powered only | 25.5 lbs (11.5 kg), AC or battery-powered |
| Dimensions (W x D x H) | 51.2″ x 11.2″ x 6″ (130.1 x 28.4 x 15.2 cm) | 52″ x 9.1″ x 4″ (132.2 x 23.1 x 10.2 cm) |
| Finish Options | Black, White | Black, White, Red |
| My individual reviews | Roland FP-30X review | Casio PX-S1100 review |
Key Takeaways from the Comparison
- Roland FP-30X: Offers a more realistic key action, richer sound engine, higher polyphony, and robust connectivity options for professional use. Ideal for intermediate to advanced players.
- Casio PX-S1100: Focuses on portability, modern aesthetics, and wireless convenience, making it an excellent choice for casual players and those on the go.
Your choice depends on whether you prioritize authentic piano performance or modern, portable convenience.
Design and Build Quality
When comparing digital pianos, the design and build quality are often overlooked, yet they play a significant role in the overall experience. Both the Roland FP-30X and the Casio PX-S1100 stand out in their respective ways, offering unique takes on form and functionality. Here, we’ll delve into the aesthetics, materials, portability, and practical considerations of each instrument.
Roland FP-30X: A Blend of Professionalism and Subtle Elegance
The Roland FP-30X has a clean, professional design that prioritizes functionality without sacrificing aesthetics. Its minimalistic appearance features a matte finish available in classic black or white, allowing it to blend seamlessly into any environment. Whether placed in a living room, a music studio, or a classroom, the FP-30X’s understated look complements a wide range of settings.
Build Quality:
The FP-30X is constructed with durability in mind, reflecting Roland’s reputation for producing reliable instruments. The piano feels robust, with high-quality plastics that don’t flex or creak under pressure. Its control panel, positioned on the left side of the keyboard, features physical buttons rather than touch-sensitive ones. This design choice ensures easy navigation and reliability during playing, even in low-light conditions or when you’re making quick adjustments mid-performance.
Portability:
Weighing approximately 31 pounds (14.8 kg), the FP-30X strikes a balance between portability and stability. It is lightweight enough to be transported if needed, though it may feel cumbersome compared to more compact models like the Casio PX-S1100. However, its weight adds a sense of solidity that enhances the playing experience, particularly when performing with greater dynamic force.
Key Dimensions:
The dimensions of the FP-30X are 51.2 inches (W) x 11.2 inches (D) x 6 inches (H), making it slightly larger than its Casio counterpart. This additional depth is largely due to its onboard speaker system and traditional design, which prioritize sound quality and stability over slimness.
Aesthetics for Professional Environments
The FP-30X’s design leans toward a professional aesthetic, which may appeal more to advanced players or those who plan to use the piano for formal performances. Its rounded edges and matte finish convey durability and practicality rather than flashy modernity, making it an ideal choice for those who value function over form.
Casio PX-S1100: Sleek, Slim, and Modern
The Casio PX-S1100 represents a bold departure from traditional digital piano design, emphasizing innovation and aesthetics. Casio has positioned this model as the slimmest digital piano with 88 weighted keys, and at just 4 inches (10.2 cm) deep, it lives up to this claim. Available in black, white, and red, the PX-S1100 caters to players who appreciate a contemporary look and want their instrument to make a visual statement.
Build Quality:
Despite its slim profile, the PX-S1100 feels surprisingly sturdy. Casio has engineered the frame with precision to ensure it remains stable during intense playing. However, its glossy surface is prone to fingerprints and smudges, which can detract from its appearance if not regularly cleaned. Additionally, the piano’s lightweight construction, while convenient for portability, may feel less robust compared to the FP-30X’s heavier build.
Portability:
Weighing just 25.5 pounds (11.5 kg), the PX-S1100 is one of the most portable digital pianos in its class. Its lightweight design and slim frame make it easy to transport between gigs, lessons, or practice sessions. Furthermore, its ability to run on battery power (up to 4 hours on six AA batteries) makes it a truly portable solution for musicians who need flexibility.
Key Dimensions:
The PX-S1100 measures 52 inches (W) x 9.1 inches (D) x 4 inches (H), making it significantly slimmer and more compact than the FP-30X. This ultra-slim profile is one of its key selling points, as it can fit comfortably into smaller spaces and modern interiors.
A Futuristic Look
One of the standout features of the PX-S1100 is its touch-sensitive control panel, which lights up when powered on. This gives the piano a futuristic and intuitive interface. While visually striking, these touch controls can be less reliable than physical buttons, particularly in bright light where the illuminated icons may become harder to see. Nonetheless, the control panel contributes to the PX-S1100’s sleek, modern aesthetic.
Design Philosophy: Traditional vs. Modern
The Roland FP-30X and Casio PX-S1100 represent two distinct design philosophies, catering to different types of players.
- The FP-30X prioritizes functionality and durability, with a classic look that appeals to traditionalists and those who want an instrument that feels grounded and substantial. Its matte finish and physical buttons make it practical for heavy use, whether in a studio, home, or classroom.
- The PX-S1100, by contrast, is a testament to modern design, emphasizing portability and visual appeal. Its ultra-slim profile, lightweight frame, and glossy finish make it an excellent choice for players who want their piano to double as a design element in their home or for musicians who frequently move their instruments.
Practical Considerations
For stationary use, the Roland FP-30X may be the better option due to its robust build and greater stability. The added weight minimizes vibrations, making it ideal for dynamic playing styles. Additionally, its slightly larger frame and deeper profile provide room for more powerful onboard speakers, enhancing its sound projection.
Conversely, the Casio PX-S1100 excels in portability. Whether you’re traveling to gigs, teaching lessons, or simply rearranging your living space, its lighter weight and compact size make it far more manageable. The option to run on batteries further extends its versatility, allowing you to play virtually anywhere without needing access to a power outlet.
Attention to Detail
Both models display meticulous attention to detail in their designs:
- The FP-30X offers textured keys with an ivory feel, which enhance grip and reduce finger slippage during long playing sessions. This small yet significant detail contributes to its professional-grade experience.
- The PX-S1100 features customizable accents, such as optional wooden stands and pedal units, that allow players to tailor the piano’s look to their preferences. This makes it more versatile for those who value aesthetics and personalization.
Verdict
When it comes to design and build quality, the Roland FP-30X wins for its durability, professional appearance, and stability, making it an excellent choice for stationary use and classical playing. Meanwhile, the Casio PX-S1100 shines for its portability, sleek modern aesthetics, and innovative design features, making it ideal for players who need a lightweight and visually striking instrument.
Ultimately, the choice depends on whether you value the traditional, professional design of the FP-30X or the ultra-modern and portable nature of the PX-S1100. Both instruments succeed in delivering well-thought-out designs tailored to different needs.
Keyboard Action and Feel
The keyboard action and feel of a digital piano are critical factors that define its playing experience, as they closely emulate the tactile sensation of an acoustic piano. In this section, we’ll explore the key mechanisms, tactile feedback, weight distribution, and nuances of the Roland FP-30X and the Casio PX-S1100, helping you understand how they differ and which might be more suitable for your needs.
Understanding Keyboard Actions in Digital Pianos
Before diving into the specifics of each model, it’s important to understand what makes a digital piano’s keyboard feel authentic. Acoustic pianos use hammers and strings, which produce natural resistance and a graded feel from heavier keys in the lower register to lighter keys in the upper register. To replicate this, digital pianos employ weighted hammer-action keys.
Both the Roland FP-30X and the Casio PX-S1100 feature 88-key weighted actions, but they approach this differently, offering distinct playing experiences.
Roland FP-30X: PHA-4 Standard Keyboard
The FP-30X employs Roland’s PHA-4 Standard keyboard, a highly regarded hammer-action mechanism that combines realism, durability, and tactile responsiveness.
Hammer Action and Escapement
The PHA-4 Standard simulates the natural hammer action of an acoustic piano with a graded feel—heavier in the bass and progressively lighter toward the treble. A key feature is the escapement mechanism, which replicates the slight “notch” or “click” you feel when pressing a key lightly on a grand piano. This detail is appreciated by advanced players, as it adds authenticity and allows for refined techniques like playing softly while still engaging the key’s full range of motion.
Key Texture
One of the standout features of the FP-30X’s keyboard is its ivory-feel keys. The keys are coated with a synthetic material that mimics the texture of real ivory, providing better grip and reducing slippage during long practice sessions. This feature not only enhances playability but also adds a premium touch that players of all levels can appreciate.
Responsiveness
The FP-30X excels in capturing the dynamics of your playing. The keyboard action is highly sensitive to touch, responding accurately to variations in pressure, from delicate pianissimo passages to thunderous fortissimo chords. This dynamic range makes it an excellent choice for classical pianists who require expressive control.
Durability and Noise
The PHA-4 keyboard is known for its durability and quiet operation. Even during fast or forceful playing, the keys produce minimal mechanical noise, ensuring that the sound of your performance isn’t overshadowed by the instrument’s internal mechanics.
Overall Feel
For pianists transitioning from an acoustic piano, the FP-30X offers a familiar and satisfying feel. Its weighted keys, realistic resistance, and escapement mechanism make it a standout in its price range, appealing to both beginners and advanced players seeking authenticity.
Casio PX-S1100: Smart Scaled Hammer Action
The Casio PX-S1100 features the Smart Scaled Hammer Action Keyboard, an innovative design that combines compactness with a realistic playing feel.
Hammer Action Mechanism
The PX-S1100’s hammer action is graded, meaning the lower keys are heavier while the upper keys are lighter, much like an acoustic piano. However, unlike the FP-30X, it does not include an escapement mechanism. While this omission may not be a dealbreaker for beginners or intermediate players, advanced pianists accustomed to the tactile nuance of escapement may find the action slightly less realistic.
Key Texture
The keys on the PX-S1100 are smooth and sleek, lacking the textured ivory or ebony finish found on the FP-30X. While the smooth surface feels comfortable, it may become slippery during extended playing sessions, particularly for players with naturally sweaty hands.
Responsiveness
The Smart Scaled Hammer Action is designed to be compact, which has trade-offs in responsiveness. The PX-S1100 offers a pleasant playing experience for lighter or casual playing, but some players may notice a lack of weight or depth compared to the FP-30X. For advanced techniques or intricate classical pieces, the lighter touch of the PX-S1100 may feel less substantial.
Innovative Design
One of the most impressive aspects of the PX-S1100’s keyboard is how Casio managed to incorporate a hammer action into such a slim and portable frame. This is a testament to Casio’s engineering ingenuity, as the keyboard delivers a decent level of realism despite its compact design.
Overall Feel
The PX-S1100’s action is best suited for beginners, hobbyists, and those who prioritize portability. It offers a smooth, accessible playing experience, but its lack of escapement and lighter touch may not satisfy pianists seeking the highest level of authenticity.
Head-to-Head Comparison
1. Realism and Authenticity
- The Roland FP-30X delivers a more realistic experience thanks to its PHA-4 Standard keyboard with escapement and ivory-feel keys. It closely replicates the tactile sensation of playing an acoustic piano, making it ideal for serious musicians.
- The Casio PX-S1100 provides a simplified version of hammer action. While it offers a graded feel, it doesn’t include escapement, and the lighter touch may feel less authentic to advanced players.
2. Key Texture
- The FP-30X stands out with its textured keys, which provide a better grip and a more premium feel.
- The PX-S1100’s smooth keys are comfortable but may lack the tactile refinement found on the Roland.
3. Dynamic Range
- The FP-30X excels in responsiveness and dynamic range, capturing subtle nuances in touch and expression.
- The PX-S1100, while responsive, has a narrower dynamic range and may not handle complex dynamics as effectively.
4. Playing Style Compatibility
- The FP-30X is versatile and accommodates a wide range of playing styles, from classical to jazz to modern pop. Its weighted keys and escapement allow for advanced techniques and subtle expressions.
- The PX-S1100 is better suited for casual playing, beginners, or those who favor portability and modern aesthetics over absolute realism.
User Perspectives
Beginners and Casual Players
For those just starting or playing casually, both models offer accessible and enjoyable experiences. The PX-S1100’s lighter touch and modern design might be more appealing, especially for younger players or those who value portability.
Intermediate and Advanced Players
Serious pianists will likely gravitate toward the FP-30X for its realistic key action, tactile feedback, and dynamic range. The escapement and textured keys make it a more satisfying choice for advanced techniques and extended practice sessions.
Portability Needs
If portability is a priority, the PX-S1100 wins hands down. Its lightweight build and battery-powered operation make it a highly convenient option for musicians on the go. However, this portability comes at the cost of a slightly less realistic keyboard action compared to the FP-30X.
Verdict
The Roland FP-30X emerges as the superior choice for players seeking a realistic and authentic playing experience. Its PHA-4 Standard keyboard, with escapement and textured keys, provides a tactile and dynamic feel that closely resembles an acoustic piano. It’s a standout for advanced players and those who value a premium, expressive instrument.
On the other hand, the Casio PX-S1100 caters to a different audience. Its Smart Scaled Hammer Action offers a lighter, smoother feel that’s perfectly adequate for beginners and casual players. The slim, portable design is ideal for those who prioritize mobility and modern aesthetics over acoustic realism.
Ultimately, the decision depends on your specific needs and playing goals:
- For authenticity and advanced playing: Roland FP-30X.
- For portability and modern appeal: Casio PX-S1100.
Sound Quality and Tone
Sound quality is one of the most critical factors when choosing a digital piano, as it determines the emotional impact and realism of your playing experience. Both the Roland FP-30X and Casio PX-S1100 offer sophisticated sound engines and impressive tonal ranges, but they cater to slightly different tastes and musical styles. In this expanded section, we’ll analyze the sound engines, tonal characteristics, polyphony, and overall sound experience offered by these two digital pianos.
Roland FP-30X: SuperNATURAL Piano Sound Engine
The Roland FP-30X is powered by Roland’s highly acclaimed SuperNATURAL Piano Sound Engine, which is designed to deliver authentic, expressive piano tones. This sound engine has been a hallmark of Roland’s digital pianos for years, and its presence in the FP-30X ensures a rich, immersive tonal experience.
Piano Tone Characteristics
The FP-30X’s piano tones are warm, full, and resonant, capturing the essence of a high-quality acoustic grand piano. The dynamic range is particularly impressive, allowing players to achieve subtle pianissimo passages or bold fortissimo bursts with equal clarity and richness. Whether you’re playing delicate classical pieces or energetic jazz, the FP-30X reproduces nuances with precision.
The tones are deeply expressive, benefiting from Roland’s advanced modeling technology, which analyzes the interaction between notes, sympathetic resonance, and damper behavior. The result is a sound that feels alive and organic, particularly in sustained chords and intricate passages.
Instrument Selection
While the focus of the FP-30X is on piano tones, it offers a total of 56 instrument sounds, including electric pianos, organs, strings, and harpsichords. These secondary tones are of high quality, making the FP-30X versatile enough for various genres and styles. However, the emphasis remains on its acoustic piano sounds, which are its strongest asset.
Polyphony
The FP-30X boasts 256-note polyphony, meaning it can handle intricate passages, dense chords, and heavy pedaling without cutting off notes. This is a significant advantage for players tackling advanced pieces or using layers and accompaniments in their music. It ensures that the sound remains seamless, even in complex performances.
Customizability
The FP-30X allows players to fine-tune the sound to their preferences using the onboard settings or external apps. Adjustments like brilliance, reverb, and other parameters enable you to tailor the tone to suit your playing environment or style. This level of customization is ideal for musicians seeking precise control over their sound.
Overall Sound Quality
The FP-30X delivers a warm, expressive sound that leans toward classical and traditional styles. Its emphasis on tonal depth and realism makes it a fantastic choice for pianists who value acoustic authenticity. The piano’s rich tonal palette and detailed resonance ensure an inspiring playing experience.
Casio PX-S1100: AiR Sound Source
The Casio PX-S1100 is equipped with Casio’s AiR (Acoustic and Intelligent Resonator) Sound Source, which focuses on delivering a natural and vibrant piano tone. This engine has been refined over the years to enhance realism and tonal clarity while accommodating the compact design of the PX-S1100.
Piano Tone Characteristics
The PX-S1100’s piano tones are bright, clear, and precise, with a focus on crisp articulation. This tonal character makes it particularly well-suited for modern and pop music, where clarity and projection are often prioritized. While the overall sound may lack the warmth and complexity of the FP-30X, it compensates with a clean and direct tonal quality that is appealing for many players.
The instrument captures the subtle nuances of an acoustic piano, including damper resonance and key-off simulation. While not as intricate as the FP-30X’s modeling, these details contribute to a more realistic playing experience compared to older digital pianos.
Instrument Selection
The PX-S1100 features 18 instrument sounds, including variations of acoustic pianos, electric pianos, organs, and strings. Although the selection is more limited than the FP-30X, the quality of each tone is excellent. Additionally, Casio provides access to its Music Space app, allowing players to expand the tonal range and fine-tune various parameters, including reverb and resonance.
Polyphony
The PX-S1100 offers 192-note polyphony, which is more than sufficient for most players, including those performing moderately complex pieces with heavy pedaling. While it falls slightly short of the FP-30X’s 256-note polyphony, it is unlikely to pose any practical limitations for the majority of musicians.
Customizability
The PX-S1100 excels in customizability, particularly when paired with the Casio Music Space app. This app provides an intuitive interface for adjusting EQ, reverb, and other parameters, allowing players to shape the tone to their liking. Additionally, the app includes features for practice and performance, such as a metronome and sheet music viewer, further enhancing the overall experience.
Overall Sound Quality
The PX-S1100 offers a bright and modern tonal character that appeals to players who favor pop, rock, or contemporary styles. While its sound engine lacks the intricate modeling of Roland’s SuperNATURAL technology, it delivers a pleasing and accessible tone that is well-suited for its target audience. The portability and compact design of the PX-S1100 make its sound quality even more impressive, as it manages to achieve high fidelity within its slim form factor.
Head-to-Head Comparison
1. Tonal Characteristics
- The Roland FP-30X provides warm, resonant tones with deep, expressive dynamics. It is better suited for classical and traditional music styles, where tonal complexity and authenticity are paramount.
- The Casio PX-S1100 offers bright, clear tones with a modern edge, making it ideal for pop, rock, and light classical pieces. Its sound is clean and articulate, though it may lack the depth of the FP-30X.
2. Instrument Variety
- The FP-30X offers a wider variety of sounds (56 compared to the PX-S1100’s 18), giving it an advantage in versatility for multi-genre performance.
- The PX-S1100 compensates for its smaller library with high-quality tones and app-based expansion options, appealing to players who value simplicity and customization.
3. Polyphony
- With 256-note polyphony, the FP-30X has a clear edge for players tackling complex compositions or layering multiple sounds.
- The PX-S1100’s 192-note polyphony is more than sufficient for most playing scenarios, but it may fall short in extreme cases.
4. Modeling and Resonance
- The FP-30X’s advanced modeling technology creates a richer, more nuanced soundscape with detailed resonance and note interactions.
- The PX-S1100, while realistic, relies on simpler sampling techniques, resulting in a slightly less immersive tonal experience.
Practical Applications
For Classical Pianists
The Roland FP-30X is the superior choice for players who prioritize tonal depth and realism. Its warm, expressive sound and advanced modeling make it particularly well-suited for classical repertoire and dynamic performances.
For Contemporary Players
The Casio PX-S1100 shines in modern and contemporary genres, where its bright, clean tones and app-based customization features are most appreciated. Its straightforward and vibrant sound is also appealing for casual players or those performing in smaller venues.
For Versatility
If you’re looking for a piano with a broad tonal range and multiple voices, the FP-30X is the better option. However, if you prefer fewer, high-quality voices with modern sound-shaping capabilities, the PX-S1100 offers plenty of flexibility.
Verdict
The Roland FP-30X takes the lead in sound quality for its rich, dynamic tones and advanced resonance modeling. It excels in creating an acoustic-like experience, making it the go-to choice for those who value authenticity and expression.
The Casio PX-S1100, on the other hand, provides bright, articulate tones that cater to modern styles and casual players. Its sound quality is impressive given its slim design and portability, making it an excellent option for players who need a compact, versatile instrument.
Ultimately, your choice will depend on your musical preferences:
- For warm, resonant tones and acoustic realism: Roland FP-30X.
- For bright, modern tones and portability: Casio PX-S1100.
Speakers and Sound Projection
The built-in speaker system of a digital piano significantly impacts its ability to reproduce sound naturally and project it effectively in various settings. While external amplification is always an option, the onboard speakers are often the primary way players experience the instrument, especially for home use. Both the Roland FP-30X and the Casio PX-S1100 come equipped with respectable speaker systems, but they cater to different needs and preferences. In this section, we’ll explore their power, sound quality, placement, and real-world performance.
Roland FP-30X: Powerful and Balanced Output
The Roland FP-30X features a 22-watt speaker system, with two 11-watt speakers delivering a rich and well-rounded sound. These speakers are designed to reproduce the piano’s tones with clarity and depth, emphasizing the full range of frequencies.
Sound Quality
The FP-30X’s speaker system excels in producing a natural and balanced sound. It captures the nuances of the SuperNATURAL Piano Sound Engine, projecting everything from delicate high notes to deep bass with impressive fidelity. The speakers avoid distortion even at higher volumes, ensuring that your performance remains clear and expressive.
Power and Projection
With a total output of 22 watts, the FP-30X offers more power than many other digital pianos in its price range, including the PX-S1100. This makes it suitable for home practice, small performances, or accompaniment scenarios without requiring external amplification. The sound is strong enough to fill medium-sized rooms, and the added power provides a sense of presence and immersion that elevates the playing experience.
Speaker Placement
The speakers are positioned underneath the keyboard, which helps project sound directly toward the player. This placement enhances the feeling of connection to the instrument, as the sound seems to emanate naturally from the keys. However, since the speakers are downward-facing, the sound might feel slightly muted when playing on soft surfaces like carpets. Placing the piano on a sturdy stand or hard surface can help maximize projection.
Casio PX-S1100: Compact and Immersive Surround Sound
The Casio PX-S1100 is equipped with a 16-watt speaker system, featuring two 8-watt speakers. While less powerful than the FP-30X’s system, the PX-S1100 employs innovative design features to compensate for its lower wattage.
Sound Quality
The PX-S1100 produces a clean and vibrant sound, well-suited for its bright and modern tonal character. The speakers deliver clarity across the frequency range, with the midrange and treble frequencies standing out most prominently. However, the bass response is slightly less pronounced compared to the FP-30X, which may leave the sound feeling lighter.
Power and Projection
With a total output of 16 watts, the PX-S1100 is less powerful than the FP-30X. While this wattage is sufficient for home practice or small gatherings, it may struggle to fill larger rooms without external amplification. Nevertheless, the sound is immersive within its power range, particularly when the piano is placed on a hard surface that reflects sound efficiently.
Speaker Placement
One of the standout features of the PX-S1100 is its speaker placement and sound design, which creates a surround-sound effect. The speakers are strategically positioned to provide an enveloping listening experience, making the sound feel richer and more spacious. This design compensates for the lower wattage, ensuring the piano still sounds dynamic and engaging for the player.
Head-to-Head Comparison
1. Power Output
- The Roland FP-30X has a clear advantage with its 22-watt speaker system, offering more power and projection for larger spaces.
- The Casio PX-S1100 is more compact and efficient, but its 16-watt system may feel underpowered for louder performances.
2. Sound Quality
- The FP-30X produces a fuller, richer sound with greater emphasis on bass and overall balance.
- The PX-S1100 delivers bright and clear tones, with an immersive surround-sound effect that enhances its listening experience in smaller spaces.
3. Speaker Placement
- The FP-30X’s speakers are downward-facing, which can occasionally result in muffled sound on soft surfaces.
- The PX-S1100’s speaker placement is optimized for surround sound, making it feel more spacious despite its lower wattage.
Practical Applications
For players who prioritize sound projection and plan to use their digital piano in larger spaces or performances, the Roland FP-30X is the better option. Its more powerful speakers and balanced output make it suitable for situations where volume and richness are essential.
On the other hand, the Casio PX-S1100 is ideal for home use or intimate settings, where its surround-sound effect and bright tonal character shine. Its compact and lightweight design ensures that the speakers perform well within the constraints of a smaller space, offering an engaging and enjoyable experience.
Verdict
The Roland FP-30X outshines the Casio PX-S1100 in terms of power and sound projection, making it a stronger choice for players who need robust performance across various environments. However, the Casio PX-S1100 compensates for its lower power with innovative surround sound and clarity, making it a practical and enjoyable option for casual players and those who value portability.
Ultimately, the choice depends on your specific needs:
- For powerful, room-filling sound: Choose the Roland FP-30X.
- For compact and immersive sound in small spaces: Choose the Casio PX-S1100.
Functions and Features
Digital pianos are no longer just about mimicking the sound and feel of an acoustic instrument; they now come packed with a wide range of features to enhance the playing experience, support learning, and expand creative possibilities. Both the Roland FP-30X and the Casio PX-S1100 include a host of modern functionalities that cater to beginners, hobbyists, and advanced players. However, their approaches to usability and innovation differ significantly. In this section, we’ll explore their features in detail, focusing on play modes, recording capabilities, customization, Bluetooth integration, pedal support, and unique offerings.
Roland FP-30X: Advanced Features for Musicians of All Levels
The Roland FP-30X is a feature-rich digital piano designed for players who value versatility and customization. Its functions cater to both practice and performance, offering advanced capabilities for serious musicians while remaining accessible to beginners.
Play Modes
The FP-30X includes several play modes that expand its versatility:
- Split Mode: Allows you to divide the keyboard into two distinct instrument sounds, such as bass in the lower register and piano in the upper register. This is useful for jazz and accompaniment scenarios.
- Dual Mode (Layering): Enables two instrument sounds to be layered together, such as strings and piano, for a fuller and more dynamic sound.
- Twin Piano Mode: Splits the keyboard into two identical pitch ranges, allowing two players to perform simultaneously. This mode is particularly useful for teaching, as a teacher and student can sit side by side and play together.
Recording Capabilities
The FP-30X offers an onboard MIDI recorder that allows players to capture their performances and analyze them later. While the onboard recorder saves MIDI data, you can also connect a USB drive to save your performances as audio files (WAV format). This feature is ideal for students tracking their progress or musicians creating demos and ideas.
Customization Options
The FP-30X provides a range of customization settings to adjust the sound and playing experience:
- Brilliance: Adjusts the tonal brightness or darkness of the piano sound.
- Reverb and Ambience: Simulates different acoustic environments, such as a small room, concert hall, or cathedral.
- Equalizer (via app): Fine-tune the balance of bass, midrange, and treble frequencies for a personalized sound.
These options make the FP-30X adaptable to various musical styles and environments.
Bluetooth Integration
The FP-30X includes Bluetooth MIDI, allowing it to connect wirelessly to compatible apps on smartphones, tablets, or computers. This feature enables players to use a variety of music apps for learning, composition, and recording, such as Roland’s Piano Every Day app. The app offers practice tools, such as a diary for tracking progress, along with a library of scores and exercises.
However, it’s worth noting that the FP-30X lacks Bluetooth audio, which means you can’t stream music directly through its speakers. For players who want to play along with their favorite tracks, this could be a minor limitation.
Pedal Support
The FP-30X is compatible with a wide range of pedal setups, including the Roland KPD-70 three-pedal unit (when paired with the matching stand). This unit provides soft, sostenuto, and damper pedals, replicating the functionality of an acoustic piano. Additionally, the FP-30X supports half-pedaling, allowing for nuanced control over sustain and resonance.
Additional Features
- Metronome: An onboard metronome supports tempo, beat, and volume adjustments, aiding practice and rhythm training.
- Transpose Function: Allows you to shift the pitch of the keyboard, making it easier to play in different keys.
- Connectivity: The FP-30X includes USB Type-B and USB Type-A ports, allowing it to connect to computers for MIDI control or to save performances directly to a USB drive.
Casio PX-S1100: Modern Features in a Sleek Package
The Casio PX-S1100 is designed with portability, simplicity, and innovation in mind. While it offers fewer advanced features than the FP-30X, its emphasis on modern technology and user-friendly design makes it a compelling option for casual players and tech-savvy musicians.
Play Modes
The PX-S1100 includes several versatile play modes:
- Split Mode: Like the FP-30X, this divides the keyboard into two sections with different instrument sounds.
- Layering Mode: Combine two sounds to create rich and dynamic textures.
- Duet Mode: Casio’s version of Twin Piano Mode splits the keyboard into two equal pitch ranges, making it ideal for teaching and partner practice.
While these modes are similar to those on the FP-30X, the PX-S1100’s streamlined control interface makes them easy to activate and adjust.
Bluetooth Integration
The PX-S1100 excels in Bluetooth functionality, offering both Bluetooth MIDI and Bluetooth audio. With Bluetooth audio, you can stream music directly through the piano’s speakers, turning it into a high-quality sound system. This feature is particularly useful for play-along sessions or simply enjoying music during breaks.
Casio’s Music Space app enhances the Bluetooth experience, providing intuitive controls for sound adjustments, access to scores, and interactive lessons. The app also includes practice tools, such as a metronome and a tempo trainer, making it an excellent companion for learners.
Portability and Battery Operation
One of the standout features of the PX-S1100 is its ability to run on six AA batteries, offering up to four hours of playing time. This makes it an incredibly portable option for musicians who need flexibility, whether practicing outdoors, gigging at small venues, or moving between teaching locations.
Pedal Support
The PX-S1100 comes with a single sustain pedal, but it is compatible with Casio’s SP-34 three-pedal unit, which adds soft and sostenuto functionality. While it doesn’t support half-pedaling like the FP-30X, the pedal options are sufficient for most casual and intermediate players.
Recording Capabilities
The PX-S1100 includes an onboard MIDI recorder, allowing you to capture your performances for review or playback. While it doesn’t offer direct audio recording to USB like the FP-30X, its integration with the Music Space app provides an alternative for saving and sharing your work digitally.
Additional Features
- Touch-Responsive Controls: The PX-S1100’s illuminated touch controls are sleek and intuitive, providing easy access to essential functions. However, they may be less reliable in bright light compared to physical buttons.
- Transpose Function: Like the FP-30X, the PX-S1100 includes a transpose function for shifting the pitch of the keyboard.
- Metronome: A built-in metronome aids with rhythm training, offering adjustable tempo and beat settings.
- Customizable Reverb and EQ: Via the app, players can adjust reverb settings and fine-tune the EQ to suit their preferences.
Head-to-Head Comparison
1. Play Modes
Both pianos offer Split, Layering, and Duet/Twin Piano Modes, but the Roland FP-30X has a slight edge with more flexibility and depth in its sound layering and split features.
2. Recording Features
The Roland FP-30X outshines the PX-S1100 with its ability to save audio recordings directly to a USB drive, which is highly convenient for musicians who want to capture and share their performances easily.
3. Bluetooth Capabilities
The Casio PX-S1100 leads in Bluetooth functionality, thanks to its inclusion of both MIDI and audio streaming. This modern feature makes it more appealing for tech-savvy players and casual users.
4. Portability and Battery Power
The PX-S1100 is the clear winner in portability, offering battery operation and a lightweight design, which the FP-30X lacks.
5. Pedal Functionality
The FP-30X takes the lead with half-pedaling support and compatibility with advanced pedal setups, providing a more authentic playing experience.
Verdict
The Roland FP-30X is better suited for serious musicians who prioritize advanced features, such as audio recording, half-pedaling, and deeper sound customization. Its robust play modes and connectivity options make it a versatile tool for both practice and performance.
The Casio PX-S1100, on the other hand, caters to modern players who value portability, simplicity, and Bluetooth audio integration. Its lightweight design, battery operation, and app connectivity make it an excellent choice for casual use and on-the-go musicians.
Your choice will depend on your priorities:
- For advanced features and versatility: Choose the Roland FP-30X.
- For portability and modern tech: Choose the Casio PX-S1100.
Connectivity
Connectivity is a key consideration for modern digital pianos, as it affects how the instrument interacts with other devices, integrates into recording setups, and supports additional learning tools. Both the Roland FP-30X and the Casio PX-S1100 offer various connectivity options, but they take slightly different approaches to meet the needs of musicians. In this section, we’ll explore their physical ports, wireless capabilities, app integrations, and overall connectivity experience.
Roland FP-30X: Comprehensive and Professional Connectivity
The Roland FP-30X is equipped with a range of connectivity options designed to meet the needs of students, home players, and professional musicians. Whether you’re connecting to a computer, amplifier, or smartphone, the FP-30X offers the flexibility needed for various musical applications.
Physical Ports
- USB Type-B:
The FP-30X features a standard USB Type-B port, which allows the piano to act as a MIDI controller. This connection enables the FP-30X to interface with digital audio workstations (DAWs) and software instruments, making it a powerful tool for recording, arranging, and composing. With this feature, you can use the FP-30X to trigger virtual instruments or record MIDI performances directly into your computer. - USB Type-A:
Another standout feature is the USB Type-A port, which supports external storage devices such as USB flash drives. This port allows players to save their performances as WAV audio files directly onto a USB drive, a highly convenient option for recording or sharing music without requiring a separate computer. - 1/4-Inch Stereo Outputs:
The FP-30X is equipped with dual 1/4-inch stereo line outputs, which provide professional-grade connectivity for external amplification. These outputs are ideal for live performances, as they deliver a clean, unbalanced signal to external speakers or PA systems. Unlike relying solely on the onboard speakers, these outputs ensure that your sound retains clarity and power when scaled for larger venues. - Headphone Jack:
The FP-30X includes a standard 1/4-inch headphone jack, allowing for private practice sessions. The high-quality output ensures minimal distortion, delivering a satisfying and immersive listening experience when using headphones.
Bluetooth Connectivity
The FP-30X supports Bluetooth MIDI, enabling wireless communication with a wide range of music apps on tablets, smartphones, and computers. This feature is particularly useful for players who want to integrate their piano into a digital learning or recording environment.
For example, Roland’s Piano Every Day app connects seamlessly with the FP-30X, providing access to sheet music, practice tools, and performance tracking. Other apps, such as GarageBand or Synthesia, can also utilize the FP-30X’s MIDI signal for music creation and interactive lessons.
However, one limitation is that the FP-30X does not support Bluetooth audio streaming, meaning you cannot play music from your phone through the piano’s speakers. While this may not be a dealbreaker for most players, it’s a feature offered by the Casio PX-S1100, giving it an edge in this area.
Integration into Professional Setups
The FP-30X’s physical connectivity options, particularly its stereo outputs and USB Type-B functionality, make it an excellent choice for studio and live use. The ability to connect directly to DAWs or external speakers ensures a seamless workflow for recording and performance. For musicians who need a reliable instrument that fits easily into professional setups, the FP-30X delivers outstanding versatility.
Casio PX-S1100: Modern and Streamlined Connectivity
The Casio PX-S1100 is designed with simplicity and modern technology in mind. While it offers fewer physical ports than the FP-30X, its focus on wireless connectivity and app integration makes it a highly accessible and user-friendly option for today’s musicians.
Physical Ports
- USB Type-B:
The PX-S1100 includes a USB Type-B port, which functions as a MIDI interface for connecting the piano to a computer. This allows the PX-S1100 to act as a MIDI controller for DAWs or virtual instruments, similar to the FP-30X. - Headphone Jack:
Like the FP-30X, the PX-S1100 features a standard headphone jack for private practice. While the sound quality is excellent, the lack of a secondary headphone jack or additional audio outputs limits its usability in certain scenarios, such as teaching or live performances.
Notable Limitations in Physical Ports:
The PX-S1100 does not include dedicated line outputs, which can be a drawback for players who intend to use the piano in live settings. Instead, users must rely on the headphone jack for external audio connections, which may not provide the same level of sound quality and reliability as the FP-30X’s dedicated outputs.
Bluetooth Connectivity
The PX-S1100 stands out with its dual Bluetooth functionality, supporting both MIDI and audio streaming. This feature allows you to wirelessly connect to learning and recording apps while also using the piano’s speakers to stream music from your smartphone or tablet.
Bluetooth Audio Streaming
This functionality turns the PX-S1100 into a high-quality speaker system, making it easy to play along with backing tracks, stream music during breaks, or practice with online tutorials. The ability to combine Bluetooth MIDI and audio provides a seamless experience for players who prioritize modern connectivity options.
Casio Music Space App
The PX-S1100 integrates with Casio’s Music Space app, a versatile companion that enhances the overall playing experience. Through the app, players can:
- Adjust sound parameters, such as reverb and EQ.
- Access a library of scores and exercises.
- Use interactive learning tools, including a metronome and lesson features.
The app also includes additional instrument tones and sound settings, giving players more flexibility to customize their experience. The intuitive interface of Music Space makes the PX-S1100 particularly appealing for tech-savvy users and beginners.
Portability and Practicality
While the PX-S1100 may not offer as many physical connectivity options as the FP-30X, its lightweight design and battery-powered operation add another layer of practicality. Musicians who need a portable, wireless solution will find the PX-S1100’s connectivity features more than sufficient for casual performances and at-home practice.
Head-to-Head Comparison
1. Physical Ports
- The Roland FP-30X provides more robust physical connectivity with its USB Type-A, USB Type-B, stereo line outputs, and high-quality headphone jack.
- The Casio PX-S1100 includes only a USB Type-B port and a headphone jack, which may limit its versatility in professional settings.
2. Bluetooth Functionality
- The PX-S1100 excels with both Bluetooth MIDI and Bluetooth audio streaming, offering a more modern and user-friendly wireless experience.
- The FP-30X, while supporting Bluetooth MIDI, lacks audio streaming capabilities, which may be a disadvantage for players who want to stream music through the piano’s speakers.
3. App Integration
- Both pianos integrate with useful apps, but the Casio Music Space app offers more intuitive controls and additional features, such as access to tones and reverb customization.
- The FP-30X’s Piano Every Day app focuses more on practice and progress tracking, making it ideal for students.
4. Professional Applications
- The Roland FP-30X is better suited for studio and stage use, thanks to its stereo line outputs and ability to save audio recordings directly to USB drives.
- The Casio PX-S1100, with its Bluetooth audio streaming and battery-powered portability, is a better fit for casual players and on-the-go musicians.
Verdict
The Roland FP-30X is the clear winner for musicians who need advanced connectivity options for professional setups. Its comprehensive ports and USB recording capabilities make it ideal for studio use, live performances, and serious practice.
On the other hand, the Casio PX-S1100 is perfect for players who prioritize portability and modern wireless features. Its dual Bluetooth functionality and intuitive app integration create a seamless and convenient experience for casual practice and tech-savvy users.
Choose the Roland FP-30X for robust physical connections and professional applications. Opt for the Casio PX-S1100 if you value wireless convenience and sleek, modern functionality.
Value for Money
When evaluating the Roland FP-30X and Casio PX-S1100, their value for money comes down to how well their features, build quality, and performance justify their price tags. Both models offer excellent value within their respective categories, but their appeal differs depending on the priorities of the buyer.
Roland FP-30X: Superior Features for Serious Musicians
Priced slightly higher than the Casio PX-S1100, the Roland FP-30X is a strong investment for musicians seeking an authentic piano experience. Its PHA-4 Standard keyboard with escapement, 256-note polyphony, and SuperNATURAL Piano Sound Engine provide a level of quality that rivals many higher-end digital pianos.
The inclusion of stereo line outputs, USB audio recording, and professional-grade pedal compatibility makes it a versatile choice for live performances, studio use, and advanced practice. While it lacks Bluetooth audio streaming and battery power, the FP-30X more than compensates with its robust sound projection, durability, and expressive playing capabilities.
For those who prioritize tonal depth, realistic key action, and advanced connectivity for professional applications, the FP-30X offers exceptional long-term value despite its higher initial cost.
Casio PX-S1100: Affordable Innovation for Everyday Players
The Casio PX-S1100 provides excellent value for those who want a modern, portable, and user-friendly digital piano. Its slim design, dual Bluetooth functionality, and battery operation make it a standout in terms of convenience and portability. Priced more affordably than the FP-30X, it delivers a bright and vibrant tone, intuitive app integration, and an impressive playing experience for its compact size.
Although it lacks the advanced features and premium feel of the FP-30X, the PX-S1100 is ideal for beginners, hobbyists, and musicians on the go. Its affordability, combined with cutting-edge features, makes it one of the best options for tech-savvy and casual players alike.
Verdict
- For professional-level features and long-term investment: Roland FP-30X.
- For affordability, portability, and modern convenience: Casio PX-S1100.
Final Verdict
The Roland FP-30X and the Casio PX-S1100 are both excellent digital pianos, but they cater to distinct needs and playing styles. Choosing between them depends on your priorities, whether they lean toward realism, portability, advanced features, or modern conveniences.
Roland FP-30X: For the Serious Musician
The Roland FP-30X is an outstanding choice for players seeking a realistic, expressive playing experience. Its PHA-4 Standard keyboard with escapement provides exceptional tactile feedback, closely mimicking the feel of an acoustic piano. Combined with the SuperNATURAL Piano Sound Engine, the FP-30X delivers rich, resonant tones suited for classical, jazz, and other dynamic genres.
Beyond its performance features, the FP-30X excels in connectivity and professional applications. With 256-note polyphony, USB recording, and stereo line outputs, it’s ideal for serious practice, live performances, and recording. While it lacks Bluetooth audio streaming and battery-powered operation, its focus on authenticity and versatility makes it a fantastic long-term investment for intermediate to advanced players.
Casio PX-S1100: For the Modern Player
The Casio PX-S1100 is perfect for those who prioritize portability, modern aesthetics, and wireless convenience. Its slim design and lightweight frame make it the most portable option in its class, while its dual Bluetooth functionality allows for seamless integration with smart devices. With 192-note polyphony, a bright tonal character, and intuitive app-based controls, it’s an excellent choice for casual players, tech-savvy users, and those who value convenience.
Although it lacks some advanced features like USB audio recording and half-pedaling, its affordability, battery operation, and sleek design make it one of the best options for beginners and hobbyists on the go.
Which to Choose?
- Choose the Roland FP-30X if you want a professional-grade instrument with realistic feel, rich tone, and advanced connectivity.
- Choose the Casio PX-S1100 if you prefer a modern, portable, and budget-friendly piano with cutting-edge wireless features.