Digital pianos have grown in popularity for their versatility, affordability, and compact design. For anyone choosing a beginner-to-intermediate-level digital piano, the Donner DEP-20 and the Yamaha P71 often come up as strong contenders. Both pianos are aimed at providing a fulfilling playing experience with quality features at competitive prices. However, they cater to slightly different needs and preferences, making it essential to dive deeper into their specifications and performance.
This review compares the two models across multiple categories: design, keyboard quality, sound quality, speakers, functions, connectivity, and value for money. By the end, you’ll have a clear understanding of which digital piano suits your specific requirements.
Donner DEP-20 vs Yamaha P71 Comparison Chart
If you click the links below, under the product images you will be redirected to Amazon.com. In case you then decide to buy anything, Amazon.com will pay me a commission. This doesn’t affect the honesty of this review in any way though.
| Feature | Donner DEP-20 | Yamaha P71 |
|---|---|---|
 |  | |
| Check best price on Amazon | Check best price on Amazon | |
| Design | Modern design with matte finish; includes LCD screen | Minimalist design with matte finish; no LCD screen |
| Weight | 26 lbs (11.8 kg) | 25 lbs (11.3 kg) |
| Keyboard | 88 fully weighted keys with hammer action simulation | 88 fully weighted keys with Graded Hammer Standard (GHS) action |
| Key Texture | Smooth plastic | Matte finish mimics ivory and ebony |
| Polyphony | 128 notes | 64 notes |
| Voices | 238 built-in tones, including acoustic pianos, electric pianos, organs, strings, synths, and more | 10 high-quality voices, including 2 grand pianos, electric pianos, organs, and strings |
| Sound Technology | Basic sampling | Advanced Wave Memory (AWM) sampling |
| Speaker System | Two 25W speakers | Two 6W speakers |
| Dual Mode | Yes | Yes |
| Split Mode | Yes | No |
| Rhythms | 100 built-in rhythm accompaniments | No |
| Recording Capability | 2-track recording and playback | No |
| Transpose and Tuning | Yes | Yes |
| Sustain Pedal | Included (basic); supports full pedal units | Included (basic); supports single pedal only |
| Connectivity | USB-MIDI, headphone jack, audio outputs, sustain pedal input | USB-MIDI, headphone jack, sustain pedal input |
| Audio Outputs | Yes (dedicated 1/4″ outputs for external speakers) | No (must use headphone jack as a workaround) |
| Price | ~$400 | ~$500 |
| Best For | Beginners and hobbyists seeking features and versatility | Pianists focused on tone quality and authentic feel |
| My product reviews | Donner DEP-20 review | Yamaha P71 review |
Design and Build Quality
Design and build quality are often overlooked when selecting a digital piano, but they play a critical role in how a piano feels, looks, and functions over time. Both the Donner DEP-20 and Yamaha P71 have distinct designs catering to their intended audiences. In this section, we will dive deeper into the aesthetic, build materials, portability, control layout, and overall practicality of each model.
Donner DEP-20
The Donner DEP-20 is a prime example of a piano designed with the modern musician in mind. At first glance, it has a contemporary look with clean lines and a sleek matte finish that resists fingerprints and smudges. The piano’s lightweight construction at approximately 26 lbs (11.8 kg) makes it highly portable, suitable for players who may need to move it frequently, whether between rooms at home or to practice spaces and small gigs.
Aesthetic Appeal
The DEP-20 features an understated but stylish appearance, with a black plastic body accented by a simple control panel. The build quality reflects its budget-friendly price range, with a durable but lightweight plastic construction. While it doesn’t feel as premium as higher-end digital pianos, it doesn’t come across as flimsy either. It manages to strike a balance between affordability and functionality, making it appealing for beginners and casual players.
Control Layout
One of the standout aspects of the DEP-20’s design is its LCD screen. Positioned in the center of the control panel, the screen is both practical and user-friendly. It provides real-time feedback on settings, tones, and functions, which is especially helpful for beginners unfamiliar with navigating digital piano interfaces. The screen is flanked by a series of buttons that control everything from tone selection to rhythm accompaniments and playback features. While there are a lot of buttons, they’re clearly labeled, and the layout is intuitive enough for most users to navigate without needing to consult the manual constantly.
Portability and Practicality
The DEP-20’s lightweight nature and compact design make it an excellent choice for musicians on the go. However, there’s a trade-off in terms of sturdiness. While the piano is stable on a solid stand, it doesn’t have the weight and build robustness that some players might expect, particularly if they’re accustomed to acoustic pianos or higher-end digital models. For home use and light travel, this isn’t a significant drawback, but for more demanding gig setups, the lightweight design might feel less reliable.
Durability
In terms of long-term durability, the DEP-20’s plastic construction is standard for its price range but may not hold up as well under heavy use compared to higher-end instruments. The keys, while functional, feel slightly less sturdy than the Yamaha P71’s. However, for beginners or casual players who don’t plan to move the piano frequently or subject it to rigorous conditions, the DEP-20’s build is more than adequate.
Yamaha P71
The Yamaha P71 carries a minimalist and professional design philosophy that Yamaha is renowned for. Unlike the Donner DEP-20, which leans towards a feature-packed, accessible aesthetic, the P71 adopts a sleek, no-frills approach. It exudes simplicity and elegance, focusing on functionality rather than flashy features.
Aesthetic Appeal
The P71’s design reflects Yamaha’s dedication to crafting instruments with timeless appeal. It has a matte black finish, devoid of excessive buttons or overly prominent branding, which gives it a clean and polished look. This minimalist approach makes the P71 feel more sophisticated and professional, appealing to players who prioritize a piano that blends seamlessly into any environment, whether at home, in a studio, or on stage.
The design is understated, but it doesn’t feel boring. Instead, it conveys a sense of reliability and purpose, emphasizing Yamaha’s commitment to producing quality instruments that perform exceptionally well without unnecessary distractions.
Control Layout
In keeping with its minimalist ethos, the P71 features a button-based control system with no LCD screen. While this contributes to the piano’s sleek appearance, it can make navigation less intuitive for some users, particularly beginners. Most functions are accessed by pressing combinations of buttons and specific keys, which requires memorization or frequent reference to the manual.
While some may find this system less user-friendly than the DEP-20’s button-and-LCD interface, others might appreciate the simplicity it brings to the design. The lack of an LCD screen also reduces the likelihood of damage or malfunctions, which could appeal to users looking for a more durable, streamlined interface.
Portability and Practicality
At 25 lbs (11.3 kg), the Yamaha P71 is slightly lighter than the DEP-20, making it equally portable and easy to transport. Its compact dimensions make it ideal for small spaces, a common concern for many beginners or home users. Whether placed on a dedicated stand or a sturdy desk, the P71 feels stable and secure.
Durability
Durability is one of Yamaha’s hallmarks, and the P71 lives up to this reputation. Its build quality is exceptional for its price point, with a sturdier feel than the DEP-20. The keys are well-constructed, and the matte finish resists wear and tear over time. The overall construction inspires confidence, making it suitable not only for home use but also for players who might need to transport the instrument occasionally.
Comparing Practical Features
Portability
Both models are lightweight and portable, but the Yamaha P71 edges out the Donner DEP-20 slightly due to its more compact design and slightly lighter weight. That said, the difference is minimal and unlikely to be a decisive factor for most users.
User Interface
The Donner DEP-20’s LCD screen gives it a clear advantage for beginners and those who appreciate visual feedback. It makes accessing the piano’s extensive features straightforward and reduces the learning curve. On the other hand, the Yamaha P71’s minimalist interface caters to players who prefer simplicity and don’t mind spending extra time learning how to use the function keys.
Aesthetic Preferences
Choosing between the two models may also come down to aesthetic preferences. The DEP-20 leans towards a modern, feature-rich appearance, while the P71 embodies a more traditional and professional design. If you prefer a piano that feels more versatile and approachable, the DEP-20 might be the better choice. Conversely, if you value timeless elegance and a premium feel, the P71 is likely to resonate more.
Conclusion
In terms of design and build quality, both the Donner DEP-20 and Yamaha P71 excel in their respective ways. The DEP-20 prioritizes functionality and accessibility, featuring a user-friendly interface with an LCD screen and an approachable aesthetic. Meanwhile, the Yamaha P71 champions minimalism and durability, delivering a professional look with exceptional build quality. Your choice will depend on what matters more to you: ease of use and versatility (DEP-20) or simplicity and a premium feel (P71).
Keyboard Quality
The keyboard is arguably the most crucial aspect of a digital piano, as it defines the tactile and expressive experience of playing the instrument. When evaluating the Donner DEP-20 and the Yamaha P71, it’s essential to examine how well they replicate the feel of an acoustic piano, their responsiveness to dynamics, and the overall playing experience. Let’s delve into the design, weight, touch sensitivity, and key action of each model to uncover their strengths and weaknesses.
Donner DEP-20
The Donner DEP-20 offers an 88-key fully weighted keyboard with hammer action simulation, a feature that aims to mimic the mechanics of a traditional acoustic piano. For its price point, this is impressive, as many budget digital pianos opt for semi-weighted or spring-action keys. While it doesn’t deliver the same level of realism as higher-end models, it provides a solid introduction to weighted action for beginners.
Key Weighting and Action
The weighted keys on the DEP-20 simulate the heavier feel of an acoustic piano’s lower register and the lighter touch of the higher register. However, the weighting is not as refined or consistent as what you’d find on more expensive instruments like the Yamaha P71. The keys have a slightly lighter resistance overall, which may appeal to beginners or casual players who prefer less physical effort during long practice sessions. That said, more experienced pianists might find the action less satisfying, as it doesn’t replicate the nuanced feedback of a traditional piano.
The hammer action simulation is a nice touch, but it falls short in offering the precision and tactile feel found in higher-quality graded hammer systems. Some keys, especially in the middle register, can feel slightly uneven in response, which becomes noticeable during dynamic or technically demanding pieces. For simpler compositions and practice routines, this is unlikely to pose a significant issue.
Touch Sensitivity
The DEP-20 features adjustable touch sensitivity, allowing players to choose how the keys respond to varying levels of pressure. This customization can be helpful for players of different skill levels. Beginners might opt for a lighter touch setting, while intermediate players can experiment with settings that offer more resistance and dynamic range. While the touch sensitivity adds some versatility, the responsiveness lacks the refined gradation seen in premium digital pianos, where even subtle changes in pressure are accurately translated into sound.
Key Texture
The keys on the Donner DEP-20 have a smooth, glossy plastic finish, which is standard in this price range. While functional, they lack the textured surface of higher-end keyboards that emulate the feel of ivory and ebony. This may lead to slight slippage during extended practice sessions or performances, particularly for players with sweaty hands.
Suitability for Beginners
For beginners, the DEP-20 is a strong contender. Its weighted keys and touch sensitivity provide an affordable gateway to the world of digital pianos with features that encourage proper finger strength and technique development. However, intermediate and advanced players looking for a more authentic acoustic feel may find it somewhat limiting.
Yamaha P71
The Yamaha P71 is equipped with Yamaha’s Graded Hammer Standard (GHS) action, a feature that elevates it above many digital pianos in its price range. GHS is Yamaha’s entry-level hammer action system, designed to provide an authentic playing experience that mimics the feel of an acoustic piano. For its price, this is one of the standout features of the P71.
Key Weighting and Action
The GHS action on the Yamaha P71 is one of its defining characteristics. It provides graded hammer action, meaning the keys in the lower register are heavier to press, while those in the higher register are progressively lighter. This subtle gradation closely resembles the mechanics of a real acoustic piano and is a significant step up from the hammer action simulation found on the Donner DEP-20.
The resistance in the keys feels balanced and consistent across the keyboard, making it ideal for players who want to develop proper finger strength and dynamic control. While the GHS action doesn’t reach the sophistication of Yamaha’s higher-end systems like the GH3 or NWX (used in premium models), it’s a reliable and realistic choice for beginners and intermediate players.
Touch Sensitivity
Like the Donner DEP-20, the Yamaha P71 also offers adjustable touch sensitivity with multiple settings. However, the P71’s touch sensitivity is more responsive, allowing for smoother transitions between pianissimo and fortissimo dynamics. This makes the P71 better suited for pieces that demand precise control over dynamics, such as classical compositions or expressive ballads.
Advanced players will appreciate the level of nuance the P71 provides, as it encourages proper technique and rewards subtle variations in touch. This responsiveness makes the P71 feel like a more serious instrument, catering to players who aspire to master complex pieces with emotional depth.
Key Texture
The Yamaha P71’s keys feature a matte finish, mimicking the texture of real ebony and ivory. This textured surface provides a better grip and reduces the likelihood of slippage, even during extended playing sessions. This small detail enhances the overall playing experience and contributes to the premium feel of the instrument.
Durability of the Keyboard
Yamaha has a reputation for producing durable instruments, and the P71 is no exception. The keys feel solid and robust, showing no signs of wobble or inconsistency. This durability ensures that the P71 can withstand years of practice and performance without degradation in its keyboard action.
Comparative Analysis
Weighting and Action
The Yamaha P71 outshines the Donner DEP-20 when it comes to key weighting and action. Its GHS system delivers a more realistic experience, with graded resistance that closely mimics an acoustic piano. The DEP-20’s hammer action simulation, while commendable for its price, lacks the consistency and refinement of the P71.
Touch Sensitivity
Both pianos offer adjustable touch sensitivity, but the P71 excels in responsiveness and dynamic range. This makes it a better choice for players who prioritize expressiveness and precision in their music.
Key Texture
The matte finish of the P71’s keys gives it an edge over the DEP-20, whose smooth plastic keys can feel slippery. This seemingly minor detail significantly enhances the playing experience, particularly for more advanced pianists.
Suitability for Different Skill Levels
- Beginners: Both models are suitable for beginners, but the DEP-20 offers an affordable option with adequate features for learning proper technique.
- Intermediate and Advanced Players: The Yamaha P71 is the clear choice for players seeking a more authentic acoustic feel and better responsiveness.
Conclusion
When it comes to keyboard quality, the Yamaha P71 is the superior option. Its GHS action, realistic touch sensitivity, and textured keys make it a more authentic and satisfying instrument to play. While the Donner DEP-20 provides a solid introduction to weighted keys and is a great budget option for beginners, its hammer action simulation and key texture fall short compared to the P71. For those who value realism and long-term growth as pianists, the P71 is well worth the investment.
Sound Quality
Sound quality is one of the most important factors when choosing a digital piano. A digital piano must convincingly replicate the rich tones of an acoustic piano while offering additional voices and sounds for versatility. In this section, we compare the Donner DEP-20 and Yamaha P71 in terms of tone quality, realism, polyphony, variety of voices, and how they perform under different playing conditions. Both models aim to balance quality and affordability, but they take different approaches to sound production and tonal depth.
Donner DEP-20
The Donner DEP-20 stands out in the budget-friendly digital piano market for its 238 built-in tones, which include not just acoustic piano sounds but also a wide variety of other instruments. For beginners or hobbyists who enjoy experimenting with different styles and genres, this range of voices adds a layer of fun and creativity to the playing experience.
Tone Quality and Realism
The main acoustic piano tone on the Donner DEP-20 is serviceable but not exceptional. While the piano tone is warm and pleasant, it lacks the depth and resonance of more advanced digital pianos. The sound can feel slightly artificial, particularly in the upper register, where notes tend to sound thinner and less realistic. In the lower registers, the bass notes carry more weight, but they sometimes lack the clarity and richness found in higher-quality samples.
Donner uses sampled sound technology to reproduce its tones, but the sampling quality isn’t as advanced as Yamaha’s. For casual playing or practice, the sound quality is more than adequate, but for serious players or those with an ear for nuance, the DEP-20 may fall short.
Variety of Voices
One of the DEP-20’s biggest strengths is its extensive collection of voices. With 238 tones to choose from, the piano can emulate a wide range of instruments, including electric pianos, organs, strings, brass, woodwinds, and even synths. This makes the DEP-20 a versatile tool for exploring different genres and creating layered compositions.
In addition to the tones, the DEP-20 includes 100 rhythm accompaniments, which provide backing tracks for practice or performance. These rhythms are particularly useful for beginners looking to improve their timing and coordination, as well as for musicians who enjoy experimenting with various styles.
Polyphony
The DEP-20 offers 128-note polyphony, which is impressive for its price range. This ensures that even when playing complex pieces with overlapping notes or using sustain, the sound remains smooth and uninterrupted. For most players, 128 notes of polyphony are more than sufficient, and the DEP-20 handles layered tones and accompaniments without noticeable dropouts.
Speaker System
The DEP-20 features two 25W speakers, delivering powerful sound output that fills small to medium-sized rooms with ease. The volume is sufficient for casual practice, home performances, and small gatherings. However, at higher volumes, the sound quality can degrade slightly, with some distortion in the bass and treble frequencies. This limitation makes external amplification a better choice for larger venues or professional settings.
Yamaha P71
The Yamaha P71 takes a different approach to sound quality, focusing on delivering fewer but higher-quality tones. With 10 voices, including two grand piano tones, electric pianos, organs, and strings, the P71 is tailored to players who value authenticity and tonal depth over sheer variety.
Tone Quality and Realism
The Yamaha P71 excels in tone realism, thanks to its use of Advanced Wave Memory (AWM) sampling technology. This technique layers multiple recordings of acoustic instruments to create a fuller, more nuanced sound. The grand piano tone on the P71 is one of its standout features, offering a rich, warm, and resonant sound that rivals more expensive digital pianos. Each note feels dynamic and expressive, capturing the subtleties of an acoustic piano.
The depth of tone is particularly evident in the lower and middle registers, where the P71 produces a natural, rounded sound. The high register, while clear and vibrant, can occasionally lack the shimmer of Yamaha’s more advanced models. Nonetheless, the overall tonal balance is excellent, making the P71 ideal for classical music, jazz, and other genres that require expressive playing.
Variety of Voices
While the P71 offers only 10 voices, their quality far surpasses those on the DEP-20. The electric piano and organ tones are particularly well-executed, with smooth transitions and a realistic timbre. This limited selection might feel restrictive for players who want to experiment with a wide array of instruments, but for those who focus primarily on piano-centric music, the P71’s voices provide an excellent foundation.
The lack of additional tones like synths or brass might be a drawback for some users, particularly those interested in modern or experimental music styles. However, Yamaha prioritizes quality over quantity, ensuring that each voice is meticulously crafted.
Polyphony
The Yamaha P71 has 64-note polyphony, which is lower than the DEP-20’s 128-note polyphony. While this may seem like a disadvantage, the P71’s superior sound engine ensures that it rarely feels like a limitation. Most players will find 64 notes sufficient for everyday use, especially for solo piano pieces. However, when playing heavily layered compositions or using the sustain pedal extensively, the lower polyphony can occasionally result in note dropouts.
Speaker System
The P71 comes with two 6W speakers, which are much less powerful than the DEP-20’s speakers. However, what the P71’s speakers lack in volume, they make up for in clarity and tonal accuracy. The sound reproduction is balanced and precise, capturing the subtleties of the AWM-sampled tones. For home use or practice in a small space, the speakers are more than adequate. For larger venues or performances, external amplification is recommended to fully appreciate the P71’s sound quality.
Comparative Analysis
Tone Realism
- The Yamaha P71 is the clear winner in tone realism. Its AWM sampling technology provides richer, more nuanced piano sounds that feel authentic and expressive. The DEP-20’s tones are serviceable but lack the depth and clarity of the P71’s samples.
Variety of Voices
- The Donner DEP-20 shines with its wide array of tones, offering far greater versatility than the P71. For players who enjoy experimenting with various instrument sounds, the DEP-20 is the better choice.
Polyphony
- The DEP-20’s 128-note polyphony gives it a technical edge, allowing for smoother playback during complex arrangements. However, the P71’s 64-note polyphony is sufficient for most players and compensates with higher-quality sound reproduction.
Speaker Performance
- The DEP-20’s speakers are louder and more powerful, making it suitable for informal performances or practice in larger spaces. The P71’s speakers prioritize clarity over volume, producing a more refined sound but lacking the output needed for larger settings.
Conclusion
The choice between the Donner DEP-20 and Yamaha P71 ultimately comes down to your priorities. If you value sound quality and tonal realism, the Yamaha P71 is the clear winner. Its AWM sampling technology and expressive grand piano tones make it ideal for serious pianists and those focused on classical or jazz music.
On the other hand, if you’re looking for versatility and variety, the Donner DEP-20’s extensive range of tones and rhythms offers a more playful and creative experience. While its main piano tone isn’t as realistic as the P71’s, its additional features make it an excellent choice for beginners or casual players exploring different musical styles.
Speaker System
The speaker system of a digital piano is a critical component that affects how well the instrument’s sound translates to the listener. It influences the overall playing experience, especially for those who prefer standalone use without external amplification or headphones. Both the Donner DEP-20 and the Yamaha P71 offer built-in speaker systems, but their designs, output power, and performance cater to different needs. Let’s examine their speaker setups in detail.
Donner DEP-20
The Donner DEP-20 is equipped with two built-in 25W speakers, which provide a combined 50W of output power. This level of wattage is impressive for a budget digital piano and ensures robust sound projection. The speakers are positioned to project sound outward, filling small to medium-sized rooms with ease. Whether practicing at home, playing for friends and family, or using it in a casual performance setting, the DEP-20 delivers ample volume without requiring additional amplification.
Volume and Power
The DEP-20’s speaker system excels in terms of volume. Even at moderate levels, the piano produces a rich and encompassing sound that can easily be heard across a room. When turned up to higher volumes, the speakers remain loud and impactful, though they can begin to lose clarity in the lower bass and higher treble frequencies. This makes the DEP-20 suitable for players who enjoy a more immersive and vibrant sound, though the slight distortion at high volumes might deter professional use without external speakers.
Sound Clarity
While the DEP-20 delivers sufficient volume, the sound clarity and tonal accuracy fall short of premium models. The bass can sound slightly muddy at times, and the midrange—where most piano tones reside—can lack the crisp detail needed for complex compositions. However, for beginners or casual players, the speaker quality is more than adequate for general practice and casual performance.
Speaker Placement
The speakers are positioned to direct sound outward, creating a wide soundstage. This placement enhances the listening experience for both the player and any listeners, though it might not deliver the refined, focused output preferred by advanced pianists.
Yamaha P71
The Yamaha P71 comes with two 6W speakers, which are significantly less powerful than the DEP-20’s setup. While the combined 12W output may seem modest, Yamaha has prioritized clarity and tonal accuracy over raw power. The speakers are designed to reproduce the P71’s superior AWM-sampled tones with fidelity, making it ideal for solo practice in small spaces or for players using headphones or external speakers in larger environments.
Volume and Power
The P71’s speakers provide adequate volume for home practice or playing in quiet environments. However, the relatively low wattage means that the sound may struggle to project in larger rooms or noisy settings without additional amplification. For beginners practicing in a bedroom or studio, the volume is sufficient, but for more dynamic playing or informal performances, an external amplifier is recommended to make the most of the P71’s rich tones.
Sound Clarity
Where the P71 truly excels is in sound clarity and tonal balance. The speakers deliver crisp and detailed audio, faithfully reproducing the nuances of Yamaha’s AWM sampling technology. The grand piano tone, in particular, shines through with warmth and precision, ensuring that even subtle dynamics and tonal variations are preserved. This focus on clarity makes the P71 an excellent choice for players seeking an authentic piano experience at home.
Speaker Placement
Yamaha has optimized the speaker placement on the P71 for a balanced sound projection. While the soundstage is narrower compared to the DEP-20, the focused output enhances tonal accuracy, making it suitable for detailed practice and nuanced performances.
Comparative Analysis
- Volume:
The Donner DEP-20 is significantly louder, making it better suited for larger rooms or casual performances. The Yamaha P71, while quieter, focuses on producing balanced sound for home use. - Clarity:
The P71 outperforms the DEP-20 in clarity, especially in preserving the nuances of its tones. The DEP-20’s speakers are louder but slightly less precise, particularly at high volumes. - Use Case:
The DEP-20’s powerful speakers make it versatile for various settings, while the P71’s speakers are optimized for quieter, more intimate practice sessions.
Conclusion
If you prioritize volume and power, the Donner DEP-20 is the clear choice, with its 50W speaker system delivering robust sound. However, for players who value clarity and accurate tone reproduction, the Yamaha P71 offers a superior listening experience despite its lower wattage. Your choice will depend on whether you need louder output or a more refined tonal balance for home use.
Functions and Features
When selecting a digital piano, its functions and features play a pivotal role in determining its versatility and overall usability. The Donner DEP-20 and Yamaha P71 cater to different needs, with the DEP-20 offering a broad range of creative options and the P71 focusing on simplicity and practicality. This section examines the core features of each model, including their modes, recording capabilities, rhythm functions, and additional tools for practice and performance.
Donner DEP-20
The Donner DEP-20 stands out for its feature-rich design, aimed at providing maximum versatility for players. With an extensive array of tones, modes, and built-in functions, it offers a playground for beginners and hobbyists looking to experiment with their sound and practice routines.
Dual Mode
The DEP-20 includes a dual mode, which allows players to layer two instrument tones together. For example, you can combine a grand piano sound with strings to create a richer, more cinematic tone. This feature is particularly useful for musicians exploring different styles or seeking to add depth to their compositions. The layering is easy to activate through the control panel, and the LCD screen provides visual feedback to ensure the correct tones are selected.
Split Mode
The split mode on the DEP-20 divides the keyboard into two distinct sections, each assigned a different tone. For instance, the left-hand section could play a bass guitar while the right-hand section plays an electric piano. This feature is excellent for players experimenting with complex arrangements or for teachers demonstrating different parts of a composition to students.
Wide Range of Tones
One of the DEP-20’s most notable features is its 238 built-in instrument voices. These tones include acoustic and electric pianos, organs, strings, brass, synths, and more. The variety allows players to explore multiple genres and experiment with diverse sounds. While the piano tones are serviceable, some of the synthesized tones can sound artificial compared to higher-end instruments, but this breadth of options makes the DEP-20 a great tool for creative exploration.
Rhythm Accompaniments
The DEP-20 includes 100 rhythm accompaniments, providing a built-in backing band for practice or performance. These rhythms span various genres, including pop, rock, jazz, and classical. Players can use the rhythms to improve their timing or add depth to their compositions. This feature is particularly appealing to beginners, as it helps them develop a sense of timing and rhythm.
Recording and Playback
For those who want to track their progress or create simple arrangements, the DEP-20 offers two-track recording and playback. Players can record two separate layers—such as a melody and harmony—and then play them back together. While this is a basic recording function compared to the multi-track capabilities of advanced digital pianos, it’s a valuable tool for beginners and intermediate players to evaluate their performance or create simple compositions.
Transpose and Tuning
The DEP-20 includes transpose and tuning functions, which are essential for playing along with other instruments or vocalists in different keys. These functions are easy to access through the control panel and LCD screen, making it straightforward for users to adapt their performance to different musical contexts.
Pedals and Connectivity
The DEP-20 includes a basic sustain pedal, but it also supports external pedal units with more functionality, such as soft and sostenuto pedals. This expandability makes it a more versatile instrument as players advance. Additionally, the piano offers robust connectivity options, including USB-MIDI, headphone jacks, and audio outputs, which we’ll cover more in the connectivity section.
Yamaha P71
The Yamaha P71 is designed with simplicity and focus in mind. It prioritizes quality over quantity, providing essential features that cater to pianists who want a straightforward playing experience without unnecessary distractions.
Dual Mode
Like the DEP-20, the Yamaha P71 includes a dual mode, which allows two voices to be layered. While the P71 only has 10 built-in voices, the quality of these sounds is exceptional, making the layering more realistic and expressive. For example, layering the grand piano with strings results in a warm, rich tone ideal for classical or cinematic compositions. This feature is easy to activate through a combination of buttons and keys, though the lack of an LCD screen requires a bit of memorization.
Focus on Core Voices
The P71 offers 10 high-quality voices, including two grand pianos, electric pianos, organs, strings, and harpsichord. While this limited selection might seem restrictive compared to the DEP-20’s 238 tones, the P71’s emphasis on quality ensures that each voice is meticulously sampled and highly expressive. The grand piano voices, in particular, stand out for their rich, realistic sound, making the P71 ideal for players focused on piano-centric music.
Transpose and Tuning
The P71 also includes transpose and tuning functions, allowing players to adapt to different musical scenarios. These features are standard on most digital pianos but are implemented effectively on the P71, maintaining its reputation for simplicity and ease of use.
Streamlined Design
The P71 does not include additional features like rhythm accompaniments or recording capabilities. While this might be a drawback for players seeking a more versatile instrument, it appeals to those who prefer a minimalist design and straightforward operation. This simplicity makes the P71 an excellent choice for classical pianists and those who value focus over experimentation.
Comparative Analysis
Versatility
The Donner DEP-20 clearly wins in terms of versatility, offering a wide range of tones, rhythm accompaniments, and recording capabilities. These features make it an excellent choice for beginners, hobbyists, and players interested in experimenting with different sounds and genres. The DEP-20’s LCD screen further enhances its usability, providing an intuitive interface for navigating its extensive features.
The Yamaha P71, by contrast, is more limited in its features, focusing on providing high-quality core voices and a simple interface. This minimalist approach appeals to players who prioritize tone quality and a straightforward playing experience over additional functionality.
User Experience
While the DEP-20’s feature-rich design is ideal for creativity, its complexity might overwhelm absolute beginners or players who prefer a simpler setup. The P71’s minimalist design ensures that players can focus entirely on their music without getting distracted by additional options.
Recording and Rhythm
The DEP-20’s recording and rhythm features are absent on the P71. For players who enjoy composing or practicing with accompaniments, the DEP-20 offers a more complete solution. However, if these features are unnecessary, the P71’s focus on quality tones may still make it the better choice.
Conclusion
The Donner DEP-20 excels in versatility, with its dual mode, split mode, rhythm accompaniments, recording capabilities, and an extensive library of tones. It’s a fantastic option for players looking for a feature-packed instrument that fosters creativity and experimentation.
On the other hand, the Yamaha P71 is designed for pianists who value simplicity and high-quality core voices over additional features. Its straightforward design and emphasis on tone quality make it an excellent choice for players focused on traditional piano performance. Ultimately, your choice will depend on whether you prioritize features and variety (DEP-20) or focus and quality (P71).
Connectivity
Connectivity is an essential factor when evaluating digital pianos, especially for modern musicians who integrate their instruments with computers, external sound systems, or other devices. The Donner DEP-20 and Yamaha P71 offer distinct connectivity options, each catering to different needs and levels of technological integration. This section examines their input/output options, compatibility with external devices, and overall flexibility in both practice and performance settings.
Donner DEP-20
The Donner DEP-20 is designed with versatility in mind, and its extensive connectivity options reflect this. Whether you’re a beginner who wants to practice with headphones, a hobbyist experimenting with recording software, or a performer connecting to external speakers, the DEP-20 provides a range of options to suit your needs.
USB-MIDI Connectivity
One of the standout features of the Donner DEP-20 is its USB-MIDI functionality. This allows the piano to connect directly to a computer or DAW (Digital Audio Workstation), enabling players to record MIDI data or use virtual instruments. For example, by connecting to software like GarageBand, Ableton Live, or FL Studio, musicians can explore a wide variety of sounds and effects beyond the piano’s built-in tones.
This feature is especially useful for aspiring composers or producers who want to incorporate their piano playing into digital compositions. The plug-and-play compatibility ensures that the piano can be connected quickly without requiring additional drivers or software.
Headphone Jack
The DEP-20 includes a standard 1/4-inch headphone jack, enabling silent practice. This is a crucial feature for home users, especially those living in shared spaces or practicing at odd hours. The headphone output is clear and balanced, providing an immersive listening experience that allows players to focus on their music without external distractions.
Audio Outputs
One of the DEP-20’s major advantages is its dedicated audio output options, which include standard 1/4-inch outputs. These outputs allow the piano to connect directly to external speakers, amplifiers, or PA systems, making it suitable for small gigs, performances, or studio recordings. This flexibility ensures that the DEP-20 can adapt to various environments, from home practice to live performances.
Sustain Pedal Input
The DEP-20 comes with a sustain pedal included in the package, and it features a dedicated pedal input for upgrading to a more advanced pedal or pedal unit. For advanced pianists who want a full suite of pedals (sustain, soft, and sostenuto), the DEP-20 can accommodate this upgrade, further enhancing its versatility.
Overall Connectivity
With its range of input and output options, the DEP-20 is a well-rounded instrument for players who want to explore both traditional and digital music-making. Whether for casual practice or more advanced recording and performance scenarios, the piano provides ample flexibility.
Yamaha P71
The Yamaha P71 takes a more minimalist approach to connectivity, in line with its overall design philosophy. While it doesn’t include as many options as the DEP-20, it provides the essentials for home practice and basic integration with other devices.
USB-MIDI Connectivity
Like the DEP-20, the Yamaha P71 features USB-MIDI support, allowing players to connect the piano to a computer or DAW. While the P71 doesn’t include additional digital features like built-in rhythms or accompaniment styles, its MIDI functionality lets users unlock these possibilities through external software.
For example, you can use the P71 as a MIDI controller, triggering virtual instruments or recording complex compositions directly into software like Logic Pro or Cubase. The simplicity of the P71’s interface ensures that it integrates seamlessly into a digital setup, making it a valuable tool for composers and producers who prioritize tone quality.
Headphone Jack
The P71 includes a 1/4-inch headphone output, providing silent practice capability. The headphone output delivers clean and accurate sound, allowing players to fully immerse themselves in Yamaha’s high-quality tones without disturbing others. This is particularly important for those living in apartments or practicing in shared spaces.
Audio Outputs
A notable limitation of the Yamaha P71 is the absence of dedicated audio outputs for external speakers or amplifiers. While it’s possible to use the headphone jack as a workaround for connecting to external sound systems, this solution may not deliver the same level of sound quality or ease of use as dedicated outputs. This can be a drawback for performers or advanced users who rely on external amplification.
Sustain Pedal Input
The Yamaha P71 includes a basic sustain pedal and a single pedal input. While it works well for beginner and intermediate players, the P71 lacks compatibility with full pedal units that offer sostenuto or soft pedal functions. For advanced pianists looking to expand their pedal setup, this limitation might be a factor to consider.
Overall Connectivity
The P71 provides the basic connectivity needed for home practice and basic recording or composing tasks. However, its lack of audio outputs and limited pedal compatibility make it less versatile than the DEP-20 in more advanced or professional settings.
Comparative Analysis
USB-MIDI Support
Both models include USB-MIDI connectivity, making them compatible with computers and DAWs for digital music production. This feature is essential for players who want to integrate their piano into a modern music-making workflow. The functionality is comparable between the two, though the DEP-20’s additional features (like rhythms and multiple tones) may offer more creative opportunities when combined with MIDI software.
Silent Practice
Both the DEP-20 and P71 feature headphone jacks, enabling silent practice. The performance of the headphone output is similar in both models, providing clean and immersive sound.
Audio Outputs
The Donner DEP-20 takes the lead in this category, thanks to its dedicated audio output options. These outputs make it easier to connect to external speakers or amplifiers without relying on the headphone jack as a workaround. This is a significant advantage for performers or those using the piano in larger spaces.
Pedal Compatibility
While both models include a basic sustain pedal, the DEP-20 offers better flexibility with its ability to support full pedal units. The P71’s single pedal input may limit advanced players who require additional pedal functionality.
Conclusion
The Donner DEP-20 is the clear winner in terms of connectivity, offering a wider range of input and output options that make it suitable for both casual and professional use. Its dedicated audio outputs, USB-MIDI functionality, and support for advanced pedal setups provide greater versatility for a variety of scenarios.
The Yamaha P71, while offering essential connectivity features like USB-MIDI and a headphone jack, takes a more streamlined approach. It’s an excellent choice for home use or as a basic MIDI controller, but it lacks the flexibility required for more advanced or performance-oriented setups. Ultimately, your choice will depend on whether you value versatility and expandability (DEP-20) or simplicity and tone quality (P71).
Value for Money
Donner DEP-20
With a price typically around $400, the Donner DEP-20 delivers exceptional value. Its wide range of features, decent sound quality, and powerful speakers make it a fantastic choice for beginners or those on a budget. While it doesn’t match the Yamaha P71 in realism, its versatility and affordability make it a compelling option.
Yamaha P71
Priced at approximately $500, the Yamaha P71 offers superior sound and keyboard action. It’s an excellent investment for pianists prioritizing realism and quality over additional features. However, the higher price and fewer features might make it less attractive for casual players or those seeking more experimentation.
Winner: Donner DEP-20 (for features) / Yamaha P71 (for quality)
The choice depends on your priorities: DEP-20 for affordability and versatility, P71 for quality and realism.
Conclusion
The Donner DEP-20 and Yamaha P71 are both excellent digital pianos, but they cater to different types of players. The DEP-20 shines with its versatility and features, including a broad range of tones, built-in rhythms, dual and split modes, and advanced connectivity options like dedicated audio outputs. It’s an ideal choice for beginners and hobbyists who want an affordable, feature-packed piano that fosters creativity and experimentation. Its powerful speakers and robust polyphony make it suitable for casual performances and practice.
On the other hand, the Yamaha P71 focuses on simplicity and quality, delivering superior sound realism and a more authentic playing experience with its Graded Hammer Standard (GHS) action and Advanced Wave Memory (AWM) technology. While it offers fewer features, it excels in tone quality, making it perfect for pianists who value a realistic, straightforward playing experience.
Ultimately, your decision will depend on whether you prioritize features and versatility (DEP-20) or authenticity and tone quality (P71).